Discuss the wiki-tag on this page. Here is the place to ask questions and propose changes.
We could instead have "praise" tags to match each of the "criticism" tags — maybe that would make more sense?
I do think the external/internal distinction matters much more for praise. We should take criticism seriously whether it comes from outside or inside of EA, but praise for EA from people who are already deeply embedded in the movement seems qualitatively different than praise from people who admire from afar.
I like having a single "external praise" tag rather than three "praise" tags corresponding to the three "criticism" tags, for the reasons you note.