All of Peter Sølling's Comments + Replies

Hi Azure

This post is now updated an now contains a structure with introduction, methodology, analysis, and conclusion. 

The abstract images with the unfortunate association to a flat Earth is also now replaced. 

Again, thank you for your good comments. 

Kind regards, 

Peter

1
Azure
4y
Hi Peter. Thank you very much for this! It's much appreciated and I'm glad my comments were somewhat helpful. Perhaps you may wish to submit the new version as a new, separate post? I think I would also contact Aaron Gertler, the forum moderator, to get some feedback if you chose to post the above as a separate post. All the best.

Hi Will

Thank you for your thoughts and suggestions. 

I have now changed the title of the post to be that which you suggested. I wanted it to be a question, but I couldn’t find a way to add a picture to a test in a question. Im new to this forum. Sorry. 

Regarding your comment on the topic, Sam Deere from the EA Fund was kind enough to answer me directly. I have replied him here in the thread. 

Best regards, Peter

7
Will Bradshaw
4y
Nice, thanks Peter. Seems like a good reason. :-)

Hi Sam

Thank you so much for your good and thorough answer.

I see from the payout overviews that the actual distribution of donation amounts between the four focus areas the past three years has followed more or less exactly the distribution indication on the sliders. Plus minus one or two percent. Now that the sliders disappear, does that mean that any future donor will not get any EA recommendation on how to balance her donation between the four areas? Or is there a recommended balance somewhere else? 
I remember here Steve Pinkers words on the EA webs

... (read more)

Hi Peter,

(Context: I have recently joined CEA to run EA Funds.)

I see from the payout overviews that the actual distribution of donation amounts between the four focus areas the past three years has followed more or less exactly the distribution indication on the sliders.

This seems to be a coincidence. Less than 10% of total donation volume is given according to the default allocation.

does that mean that any future donor will not get any EA recommendation on how to balance her donation between the four areas?

The allocation decision is based on a lot of judg... (read more)

Hi Azure!

Thanks for your thoughts. I see how the images are distorting the explanation, and I will replace the images tomorrow. I certainly did not intend to create any flat earth association. 

The “brightening” is another term for more wellbeing. I will also address this tomorrow and elaborate on introduction, methodology, analysis, and conclusion tomorrow. 

In the meantime, everything is explained in detail in my 12.000 word article on this topic linked to this post. Here, I have also made a 6000 word summary and a 3500 word summary.

Looking forwa

... (read more)

Yes, of course. Sorry. The source is a screenshot of what comes up after you press "Donate" on effectivealtruism.org.

3
Prabhat Soni
4y
Thanks!

Thanks Michael! Amazing resources, and thanks for sharing them so quickly! Have a good day! Peter

Thank you so much for you fast reply, Alex! Very helpful!