All of Sami Kassirer's Comments + Replies

Great post, thanks for sharing! I think you might find Igor Grossmann's work on the psychology of wisdom particularly interesting (https://igorgrossmann.com/projects/wisdom/), if you haven't already been exposed to it :)

2
Magnus Vinding
2y
Thanks, it looks interesting. :)

Very exciting! Is this funding specifically targeting the development of new organizations or would this also fund new academic research on this topic (e.g., antecedents and impediments to the shifting of moral values across cultures; the psychological process of moralization (as applied to EA-relevant ideas and values); barriers to longtermism thinking and interventions amongst laypeople, organizational leaders, and policymakers; etc.)? 

6
Nick_Beckstead
2y
Yes, we're open to funding academic research relevant to our mission and/or areas of interest.

Why would we have to choose between EA research being in vs. out of academia--why not both (which is kind of what we do now, right)? 

2
Linch
2y
Academia has a lot of costs and benefits. It would be moderately surprising if the costs and benefits exactly balance out (or come anywhere close) for the median EA researcher. 

I like this! However, in a perfect world, rather than there being one university (or one institute at one university) that studies global priories, wouldn't all top research universities across the world  have global priorities schools (like business or policy schools are prevalent at most research universities)? With philosophers and scientists working together in one school on having the most impact on humanity, and coordinating with one another on how to do so—where students can get PhDs in Global Priorities Research (with specialization in one of ... (read more)

2
Linch
2y
I think  is James' central claim. I personally find myself confused about how much EA research should be done in academia vs outside of it; I can imagine us moving more towards academia (or other more standardized systems) as we institutionalize. 

Love this! We could also use prisons as a place where social scientists could study how to optimize ethical development amongst criminals. These samples are so hard to access, but could produce so much impactful insight on when and why ethical decision-making fails, and how to improve ethical decision-making under conflict. This could also be coupled this with a grant competition that would fund the best ideas on how to rehabilitate inmates and improve their ethical decision-making both while in prison and after being reintegrated back into society.

How can we foster longterm global trust and status as a social movement? In order to foster global backing for some of the movement's non-normative or 'creative' ideas (e.g., build post-apocalyptic bunkers to help re-build society in case of nuclear war) that may actually be highly impactful in the longterm future, we likely need to first prove ourselves as a movement that can actually create large-scale global impact. 

Here's one idea for a megaproject that could help to foster global trust/status by proving our ability to use evidence and reason to m... (read more)