Reposting my message to Jan after reading a draft of this post. I feel like I’m *stepping into it* with this, but I’m keen to get some feedback of my own on the thoughts I’m expressing here.
Epistemic status: confident about some things, not about all of them.
Emotional state: Turbulent/conflicted, triggering what I label as fear-of-rejection as I don’t think this confirms to many unstated standards; overruled, because I must try and be prepared to fail, for I cannot always learn in a vaccuum.
Why piggy-back off this post: Because 1) it’s related, 2) my thou... (read more)
Thanks Sundanshu! Sorry for not replying sooner, I was a bit overwhelmed by some of the negative feedback in the comments.
I don't think step 1b. has the same bottleneck as current grant evaluator face, because it is less dependent on good judgement.
With your proposal, I think part of it may work, I would be worried about other parts. With step 2b I would fear nobody would feel responsible for producing the content.
With 3a or any automatic steps like that, what does that lack is some sort of (reasonably) trusted expert judgement. In my view this is ac... (read more)
Reposting my message to Jan after reading a draft of this post. I feel like I’m *stepping into it* with this, but I’m keen to get some feedback of my own on the thoughts I’m expressing here.
Epistemic status: confident about some things, not about all of them.
Emotional state: Turbulent/conflicted, triggering what I label as fear-of-rejection as I don’t think this confirms to many unstated standards; overruled, because I must try and be prepared to fail, for I cannot always learn in a vaccuum.
Why piggy-back off this post: Because 1) it’s related, 2) my thou... (read more)
Thanks Sundanshu! Sorry for not replying sooner, I was a bit overwhelmed by some of the negative feedback in the comments.
I don't think step 1b. has the same bottleneck as current grant evaluator face, because it is less dependent on good judgement.
With your proposal, I think part of it may work, I would be worried about other parts. With step 2b I would fear nobody would feel responsible for producing the content.
With 3a or any automatic steps like that, what does that lack is some sort of (reasonably) trusted expert judgement. In my view this is ac... (read more)