All of DAV1D's Comments + Replies

Aaron Gertler
3yModerator Comment11
0
0

It's nice to see the replies defuse things a bit, but this comment was unnecessarily rude. It's fine to disagree on which scenarios are plausible, but please be polite in the process.

2
Ghost_of_Li_Wenliang
3y
You should go for a Connemara; so good natured, unlike some other breeds.

I’m with Sjlver. There’s a lot of hand waving past problems in the happy timeline: eg, how long does it take to train new regulators who are going to work weekends? How quickly do trained regulators working constant overtime burn out? What happens when the Chinese government denies that the genome released early is the right one?

(Also, the invocation of “war time” as a model assumes that wars are run any more efficiently or even urgently. They’re not.)

4
Ghost_of_Li_Wenliang
3y
You seem to be mistaking this for a white paper, or a piece of legislation, or an itemized purchase order for one different timeline please. It is not that. It is instead a thing to measure our situation against, to short-circuit the useless shrugging described in the opening section. It would be difficult for more seriousness, more money, more personal and institutional courage to not help. I struggle to understand why you are so sure it wouldn't, or, if you do, why you're pointing out that unexpected things happen, on occasion. In fact the genome was released by one person, and the government didn't say anything [against the genome]. He could have done it a week earlier still.