karthik-t

Posts

Sorted by New

Wiki Contributions

Comments

[Podcast] Suggest a question for Armond Cohen of CATF

What in his experience has been the research/technology that most attracts the attention of governments and politicians? Or more generally, what has been his most successful case study of research/tech-based political advocacy?

Charitable Giving and the Exponential Distribution

Good observation, and I would add one other implication: this distribution of returns supports "hits-based evaluation" (in the spirit of hits-based giving) for interventions in global health and development. For example, consider two strategies for spending a $10 million on RCTs to evaluate some intervention: 

  1. we can evaluate 10 interventions for $1 million each, developing large samples with high statistical power. 
  2. we can evaluate 100 interventions for $100,000 each, developing smaller samples with lower statistical power. 

The traditional scientific/economic approach favors 1), since it values precisely estimating the effects of an intervention. But we care about identifying the most effective interventions - and if the returns follow an exponential distribution, the biggest effects are an order of magnitude larger than the average effects, so they will be detected even with low statistical power. Instead, we would rather maximize coverage of interventions to  maximize our probably of evaluating those high-impact interventions. If the casualty is that 60 interventions with modest effects go undetected, so be it.

Small and Vulnerable

I feel like people perceive EAs as motivated by some mysterious and unknowable drive, but stories like yours make it so understandable. I'm glad you're fighting the good fight.