All of VPetukhov's Comments + Replies

Stimulating legal response for AI misuse sounds like a great direction! The legal field around AI is super-vague now, so helping to define it properly could be a really good thing. Though I would adjust that complaining about chat-bot gaslighting can have the opposite effect by creating noise and reducing attention to more important issues. The other potential problem is that if public actions on AI are immediately punished, it would only make all AI research even more closed. It also would strengthen protective mechanism of the big corporation (the 'antif... (read more)

3
bob
1y
Yes, and seminal cases.

I summarized my view on the problem here, mainly about sanctions. And thanks to @Alex_Berezhnoy and @Ula for the links.

From what brief search provides, it can be concluded that China produces tons of masks, and was supplying it to other countries, but currently they're also on shortage. But their regulations still assume use of masks in public, so it make sense for them to prioritize their own need. See here for an example. Please, correct me if you have some other information.

3
Linch
4y
This article suggests that China's fine with shipping out masks to other countries, and also they 12x'd production in the last month or so. "Li Xingqian, director of the foreign trade department at the Ministry of Commerce, said China had not banned the export of masks or related materials during the coronavirus epidemic, despite other countries imposing such limits. “Masks are freely traded products … companies can trade them in line with market principles,” Li said. [...] "His comments pointed to Beijing’s growing confidence in its mask production capacity, after severe shortages in late January and early February. "As of Saturday, China’s daily output of masks, including surgical masks and medical N95 masks, was 116 million units, or 12 times the output at the start of February, the country’s top economic planning agency said on Monday."

Buying new masks can be a bad idea. Though there is an evidence, the problem is limited capacity of stocks. To my understanding, China produce these masks so massively that they can afford selling them to whole population. But, let's say, in US, we have the opposite situation. And massively buying masks can reduce capacity of the healthcare system, which is the main bottleneck in preventing deaths now. There are a lot of articles on this topic, and I didn't review them, but this can be an example. And from my discussion with an MD friend who works in a cl

... (read more)
3
Cullen
4y
Then shouldn't we should just buy them from China?

I'm wondering if we can address the problem with the same framework as for having better list of concrete projects? Let's say, we have a list of articles suggested for contribution, like this one, but maybe with some additional info on prioritization. A person picks the article the same way as a project and mark it somehow as "Taken" and then "Done". So we can trace their contribution based on this selection process and assign status points correspondingly. So, essentially, "Writing article" is just a possible type of a project, and the rest workflows are

... (read more)

There are only two main concerns. The first was explained in details by @saulius, and I share his vision about motivation. Having something local would allow us to design award system in the way relevant for EA community and infrastructure.

The second is different scopes of relevance between local wiki and Wikipedia. Let's say, "List of annual EA events in Europe" would be relevant for EA community, but not for the others. I'd even expect that it could be harmful for the community to have such info on wikipedia. Moreover, searchability of a local wiki is mu

... (read more)

Oh, sorry, didn't figure it out. Thanks for clarification!

Do you by chance know why the old wiki died?

Thanks for the answer!

the information in that wiki is now lost to the wind

Woh, that's sad. Some thing for us to keep in mind for the future...

This may or may not fulfil your needs (and isn't _quite_ a wiki), but the EA Hub resources (resources.eahub.org), is a repository for EA links, and we hope to grow the number of resources available.

Indeed, suggestions would solve many problems! Still, the question is how to make it appealing for contribution. I really like button "Edit" on wikipedia, as it doesn't imply complex underlying ... (read more)

This post on how to find EA documents, the forum pingbacka and asking questions on the forum are some examples of ways to find information.

That's very useful, thanks! Pingbacks especially.

There is research on what gets people motivated to write in wikipedia. Here is a recent study that found some interesting stuff, and they conclude with

Wow, so we even have some theory on that. And motivation from the paper looks aligned with EA values.

I think that we should strategically plan how to incentivize possible contributors. Ideally, people should contribut
... (read more)
2
EdoArad
4y
Re Github-like structures, I think that Google Docs can be sufficient for most cases. Instead of branches, you have non-published docs. And using a wiki page instead of issues might be fine. I agree with your analysis of knowledge bases, thanks for clarifying that! I take back the suggestion of doubling down on the forum mostly because it seems difficult to properly keep the information updated and to have a clear consensus.

Unfortunately, no. The archive there contains only the html with the main page and some logos...

Hi, as the person who personally generated the wiki dump, I can assure you that the complete content of every edit revision of every article was saved, and the data is saved in an XML format that can be trivially imported into MediaWiki. Additionally, I grabbed it after site activity had already died down, but before the wiki got taken over by spambots, so the dump should be in pretty much perfect condition.

7
riceissa
4y
wikieahuborg_w-20180412-history.xml contains the dump, which can be imported to a MediaWiki instance.

Yep, this feature would be extremely useful! Indeed, for some programming languages such customized google engines exist and works reasonably well. Don't know how they did that, but here are two examples: https://rseek.org/ and http://steampiano.net/julia-search/index.html .

Thanks, that's important piece of information! I've read only on their paper on The existential threat of antimicrobial resistance, and I think the author presents only one side and missed too much of crucial information. But as you say the variance is high, I'll take a deeper look.

Didn't know Greg was publishing there. Thanks for the comment, perhaps that's the answer!