D

D0TheMath

886 karmaJoined Jan 2019College Park, MD 20742, USA

Bio

An undergrad at University of Maryland, College Park. Majoring in math.

After finishing The Sequences at the end of 9th grade, I started following the EA community, changing my career plans to AI alignment. If anyone would like to work with me on this, PM me!

I’m currently starting the EA group for the university of maryland, college park.

Also see my LessWrong profile

Sequences
1

Effective Altruism Forum Podcast

Comments
149

D0TheMath
2mo8-11

It seems altruistically very bad to invest in companies because you expect them to profit if they perform an action with a significant chance of ending the world. I am uncertain why this is on the EA forum.

Public sentiment is already mostly against AI when public sentiment has an opinion. Though its not a major political issue (yet) so people may not be thinking about it. If it turns into a major political issue (there are ways of regulating AI without turning it into a major political issue, and you probably want to do so), then it will probably become 50/50 due to what politics does to everything.

Ah, ok. Why don't you just respond with markets then!

You can argue that the theorems are wrong, or that the explicit assumptions of the theorems don't hold, which many people have done, but like, there are still coherence theorems, and IMO completeness seems quite reasonable to me and the argument here seems very weak (and I would urge the author to create an actual concrete situation that doesn't seem very dumb in which a highly intelligence, powerful and economically useful system has non-complete preferences).

If you want to see an example of this, I suggest John's post here.

Working on it.

Spoiler (don't read if you want to work on a fun puzzle or test your alignment metal).

This effectively reads as “I think EA is good at being a company, so my company is going to be a company”. Nobody gives you $1B for being a company. People generally give you money for doing economically valuable things. What economically valuable thing do you imagine doing?

I’m not assuming its a scam, and seems unlikely it’d damage the reputation of EA. Seems like a person who got super enthusiastic about a particular governance idea they had, and had a few too many conversations about how to pitch well.

I would recommend, when making a startup, you have a clear idea of what your startup would actually do, which takes into account your own & your company’s strengths & weaknesses & comparative advantage. Many want to make money, those who succeed usually have some understanding of how (even if later they end up radically pivoting to something else).

Load more