Originally published in Sapience.org (2026).
Nick Bostrom argues that superintelligence would save the lives of people alive today. But life extension will reach the richest and most powerful first, among them the most psychopathic. We ask: is this what we want?
Nick Bostrom, the foremost philosopher of superintelligence and author of the eponymous book, released a paper in 2026 seeking to inject a measure of careful optimism into the doomsday warnings about artificial superintelligence. He points out its possible benefits:
Superintelligence would be able to enormously accelerate advances in biology and medicine—devising cures for all diseases and developing powerful anti-aging and rejuvenation therapies to restore the weak and sick to full youthful vigor
In particular, Bostrom draws our attention to the "upside both for saving the lives of currently existing individuals and for safeguarding the long-term survival and flourishing of Earth-originating intelligent life". There is no argument about the potential of the latter: climate change, poverty, pandemics, protracted regional conflicts, and other risks could be fundamentally mitigated. Our gripe is with the benefits of the former: life extension. Is saving the life of living individuals that much of a benefit to society?
The dragon also devours tyrants. In The Fable of the Dragon-Tyrant, Bostrom likens death to a dragon that devours humanity, and every year of delay in slaying it costs lives.[1] But the fable does not mention that the dragon also devours tyrants. We ask: considering those, what are the consequences?
Medicine already offers well-to-do individuals means of extending their lifespan, often well past the point of frailty. The question remains: Who exactly stands to benefit first and foremost from breakthroughs in life expectancy, and more to the point, what are the consequences to society?
Who receives the cures first. We would not argue that the life of billionaires is worth less than that of the righteous. Bostrom argues that a prioritarian weighting, which gives priority to the worst-off, makes it optimal to build superintelligence sooner. His paper does not discuss who is most likely to receive the cures first. It is nonetheless evident that those who will benefit first and foremost are the billionaire-cum-tyrant class: those with access to the resources and the means for life extension will remain that sliver of society that has lived increasingly detached lives from the reality of the vast majority of human beings. Worse: those who have accumulated legendary wealth have done so, more often than not, on the backs of others — and frequently at their expense. What are the consequences of granting the powerful and obscenely rich men an indefinite lifespan?
One comfort to the victims of the greatest historical tyrants has been their inevitable end. Do we really want to remove that last check?
Death and taxes used to be taken as the only certain things. Now reconsider with the Dark Triad of narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy in mind.[2] Of the three, only narcissism is a clinical diagnosis.[3] One consolation to the people under Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, Kim Jong Un, and Benjamin Netanyahu, among others, is the certainty of their demise. On 3 September 2025, at a military parade in Beijing attended by Kim Jong Un, a live microphone caught Putin's interpreter telling Xi Jinping that biotechnology allows organs to be transplanted again and again, until people "even achieve immortality".[4]
The last certain check. One comfort to the victims of Genghis Khan, Adolf Hitler, and Joseph Stalin has been their inevitable end. Defeat, revolution, or assassination may end a tyrant, but only old age is certain. It has been the last remaining check on the psychotic pursuit of power and wealth. Remove that certainty, and nothing stands in their path to perpetuate the subjugation and robbery of the vast majority of humans. We ask: Do we really want to discard the last check?
Dr Amnon H. Eden is a computer scientist, the Principal Scientist at the Sapience.org thinktank, and founder of Moneta Sapiens Ltd.
Comments are welcome.