Call for papers for a special journal issue on EA

William_MacAskill

Call for papers for a special journal issue on EA

William_MacAskill

1 min read · Mar 14, 2016

Comments 9

Sorted by

New & upvoted

scottweathers

10y

Thanks, Will!

I have several ideas in mind but wouldn't feel confident submitting right now, because I don't know the norms of philosophy publication. I'd love to have someone who's written for philosophy journals (preferably an EA) provide a guide to EAs who might want to submit articles. Is there anyone who might be able to address these kinds of questions?

zackrobinson

10y

Hi Scott. I've had one paper published in philosophy, and I've had several others accepted to conferences. I'm certainly not as credentialed as Will, but I might be able to give some tips. My guess is that many of these are not particularly unique to philosophy. First, it's always good to reference other relevant philosophical work. We all know what hedonistic utilitarianism is, but if you're going to write a paper about the implications of effective altruism for a hedonistic utilitarian, you should still clearly define the concept and cite major works on the topic. Second, clear writing is always preferred over convoluted writing. Sometimes people think philosophers want to sound smart and intentionally use complicated language, but the reverse is true. Sure, philosophy sometimes does legitimately require an understanding of technical terms, but good philosophical writing aims to be as clear as possible. Third, a good format to follow is abstract, introduction, argument, conclusion. Abstracts are extremely useful because they allow people to get the gist of your argument very quickly. Fourth, it is often better to make a genuine contribution to a narrow problem than to not really contribute anything to a broad topic. Finally, a good practice is probably to just read some published philosophy work. That is the best way to get an idea of the writing quality and organizational nature of publishable papers. I believe Will has some of his papers posted on his site. I've read some of his work, and I think it's a good example of clear writing. That's probably a good place to start.

Most CFPs request papers that have been prepared for blind review as well, so be sure to do that.

Thanks, Zack!

really this is a great idea i like this

very nice idea

Can anybody submit an essay or do authors have to meet certain qualifications?

RandomEA

Would it be a good idea to create an open access journal dedicated specifically to effective altruism? From what I understand, it would cost relatively little to run a website where papers could be submitted by authors, assigned to referees, evaluated by editors, and published for anyone to read. There also seems to be enough technical expertise in the community to design a website like that if there are volunteers interested in doing it. Of course, it would be a big time commitment on the part of whoever serves as the editor, but it could have significant benefits to the movement including:

-increasing dialogue between the EA community and academic philosophers

-creating a formal mechanism for receiving thoughtful feedback on new ideas

-allowing readers to find the most important new contributions in one location

-incentivizing serious research on topics that are important to the movement

-signalling the openness of the community to changing its mind on key issues

The journal could complement the various ways that new ideas are currently shared. An EA could still write a blog post to share her views, and online forums could still be considered legitimate places for serious discussion. It's just that the author of a post would now have the option of developing the idea in greater depth, a process during which she may significantly improve her argument.

The journal could be slightly different in its willingness to publish articles from authors outside the academy and select referees outside the academy. As long as the editor is an experienced academic, she should be able to ensure that the papers still meet the standards of normal philosophy journals.

Since there is currently a large unpublished literature on effective altruism, there should be enough material for the first several issues. After that, you would probably have enough submissions from people who devise arguments with the intent of getting them published in the journal.

[Edited]

Austen_Forrester

10y

What is the desired range of length, if any? Is there any provision in submitting to a journal for originality? I want to avoid writing something that is similar to something already published. I'll double check myself, of course, but I could still miss it.

Are you SURE that's the deadline? ;^)

AlasdairGives

10y

9000 words - http://commons.pacificu.edu/eip/styleguide.html

Comments

More from the author

203

300,000 lives, 100 million hens, and a world still to save

William_MacAskill·3mo ago·4m read

477

Effective altruism in the age of AGI

William_MacAskill·8mo ago·Curated 8mo ago·24m read

Announcing Deep Thought

William_MacAskill, MaxDalton·3mo ago·1m read

Curated and popular this week

Was Partisanship Good for the Environmental Movement?

Jeffrey Heninger·2y ago·Curated 3d ago·6m read

This is the third in a sequence of posts taken from my recent report: Why Did Environmentalism Become Partisan? Summary Rising partisanship did not make environmentalism more popular or politically effective. Instead, it saw flat or falling overall public opinion, fewer major legislative achievements, and fluctuating executive actions. Public Opinion...

129

Possible mistake EAs are making and shout out to Pause AI UK

Michelle_Hutchinson·5d ago·4m read

I think right now EAs might be making a significant mistake by paying insufficient attention to the political realm. As EAs we tend to figure out what’s most impactful for us to work on and focus hard. That’s great! But there are various actions that are ‘non-delegatable’ - the extent to which an individual can do the action is limited (like voting, going to a protest, making hard money contributions to particular campaigns). It might be useful if we were all more in the habit of doing variou...

108

New Video from AI in Context: The Fall and Rise of Sam Altman

ChanaMessinger, phoebe b, Aric Floyd·1w ago·3m read

New Video from AI in Context: The Fall and Rise of Sam Altman If you want to skip straight to the video, here it is! AI in Context is excited to be back with our fourth video! For those just hearing from us, we make videos for 80,000 Hours, telling stories about transformative AI...