Comment Permalink

This is a good programme but I think and strongly feel that the number of people that could be helped would be much higher if the programme was more global than just focused on the US and UK. Additionally, the value for money is higher in LMICs and hence impact is greater. For context the cost of tuition plus other fees for one person to attend Harvard for 4 years is roughly more than $300,000. This amount of money for example could fully pay for 50 undergraduate students for 4 years at top universities in Africa. So, if 10 awardees are selected for US/UK, the cost would be equivalent to 500 students in Africa for example being fully sponsored.

I am not implying that students in US and UK shouldn't receive scholarships but rather that a global eligibility could introduce a balance that would increase the ROI for each dollar spent.

See in context

Open Philanthropy Undergraduate Scholarship - New Application Round (2023/24)

by KaseyShibayama

Jul 17 20231 min read 8

19

Career choiceApplication announcementsOpen PhilanthropyFunding opportunities

Frontpage

Open Philanthropy just opened applications for the third iteration of the Open Philanthropy Undergraduate Scholarship.

Apply here.

From the program page:

This program aims to provide support for highly promising and altruistically-minded students who are hoping to start an undergraduate degree at one of the top universities in the USA or UK ([see application page for details]) and who do not qualify as domestic students at these institutions for the purposes of admission and financial aid.

The primary application deadline (recommended for students considering applying to universities in the USA) is August 18th, 2023, but there are further deadlines for candidates who do not submit their applications by this date.

Note that our funding bar for this program has risen significantly since last year; depending on the strength of the candidate pool, we think it’s possible we won’t end up awarding any scholarships to attend universities in the US and will award only a small number of scholarships to attend universities in the UK.

See the program page for additional information about funding criteria, eligible universities, application timelines, and other aspects of the application process.

Please contact undergraduatescholarship@openphilanthropy.org with any questions/suggestions.

19 Reactions

Comments8

Sorted by

New & upvoted

Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 6:45 AM

RockwellJul 17 202313

How was the list of universities determined?

KaseyShibayamaJul 28 20234

We produced our own ranking of US universities based on factors like school selectivity, academic quality of the student body, and revealed preference data (such as cross-admit yields), plus some other "soft" factors. We sanity-checked this against existing school rankings and anecdotal impressions of people who have a lot of context on the US admissions process. We primarily used national rankings to determine the UK universities in our list, along with some anecdotal evidence about Imperial being the next-best choice (after Oxbridge) for a lot of STEM students.

MichaelStJulesJul 18 20239

Will you push (or help) students to apply to "Harvard, MIT, Princeton, Yale, Amherst, Dartmouth, and Bowdoin" and other top universities that offer enough financial assistance? Getting them into one of those seems far cheaper than paying for their tuition at an expensive university without enough financial assistance.

Are there enough excellent universities or programs with enough financial assistance globally that you should just focus on helping students get into those instead of funding them to attend the top universities without enough financial assistance?

(EDIT: To be clear, by "enough financial assistance", I mean that the cost for the student after any needs-based aid, scholarships and help from their parents will be low enough to not be a significant deterrent to attending.)

JasonJul 18 20234

In the US at least, I believe there are relatively few schools that offer significant need-based financial aid to international students. But to the extent there are, spending a few thousand dollars on helping international students get into very-good-but-not-Harvard schools would seem to have a higher ROI than paying for four years at a very top school.

KaseyShibayamaJul 28 20233

We leave it up to our scholars to decide where to apply, but in our experience they're generally aware that applying to Harvard, MIT, etc. is a good idea.

We're open to offering support for admissions counseling to some applicants who don't quite meet the bar for a tuition-and-fees scholarship. (All applicants who do meet the bar are offered counseling.)

Zacharia KafukoJul 19 20235

I am not implying that students in US and UK shouldn't receive scholarships but rather that a global eligibility could introduce a balance that would increase the ROI for each dollar spent.

SanteriKJul 18 20232

Does there exist an equivalent for Master's degrees?

KaseyShibayamaJul 28 20233

We offer scholarship support to master's students via our early-career funding program.