We are AI Alignment @ Illinois. We got ~80 applicants for our fellowship program, with 40 accepted people. We are currently considering how selective we should be for our spring cohort. Since we added many new organizers, we would probably have the capacity to run more cohorts this time.
Here are some things we thought during our meeting (mentally add maybe in front of every bullet point):
Arguments for not having an application/not being selective:
- Some people are intimidated by the idea of an application process and might not apply
- A current organizer who did fundamentals in Fall 2026 mentioned that his friends thought of club applications like these exclusive business clubs
- More people will go to our fundamentals course if they try it first
- They will tell their friends to later apply after liking it
- We might be bad at predicting who will do well at our intro course
- We might be able to persuade people who would otherwise be working on normal ML research into working on AI safety
Arguments for having an application/being selective:
- Making an application would make people more committed
- More prestige for the program
- Applications might filter for people who are more into AI safety
- People who are good at writing applications will fare well later on, as much of AI safety involves applying to things
- We do not want people to treat us as a generic ML upskilling place
- Our impact and our funder's theory of change likely comes from a few exceptional people rather than a lot of people
Alternatives we are considering to our current structure:
- Make our foundations course open to anyone for the first 2 weeks then require application
- Frame it as an interest form rather than an application
- Accept more applicants and run more cohorts
We would appreciate your thoughts on our selection process, or any experiences and thoughts you had with your existing group.
You're probably right that your impact and funders' theory of change comes from the most capable and engaged people, but those people are often also busy or have many interests. An underrated cost of applications is just that they add friction, which selects for people who have time and motivation to fill out applications. You mention "intimidation" but it also just takes time and activation energy to fill out an application without a clear payoff.
The main costs or risks from reducing friction are if the group becomes so large and low engagement as to distract from the intended content.
(I started an EA group at UIUC when I was a student 5 years ago. On summer logic I didn't run a "fellowship" structure at all, against the advice of CEA, and instead spent their money on food to run weekly meetings themed around brief slides and discussion aligned to attendee interest. At least two out of <20 regular attendees work full time on AI safety, though I'm not sure what the counterfactual was.)