Recently I watched this video :
Truthfully speaking, I am by no means a conservative and think PragerU is very problematic.
I would say I am Democratic-aligned though not necessarily far-left.
I've been thinking about whether the effective altruism movement should reconsider its approach to providing continuous foreign aid to impoverished African countries.
I wonder whether we sometimes focus too heavily on the immediate benefits of aid while overlooking its potential long-term consequences.
My concern isn't necessarily that foreign aid is inherently bad (perhaps in moments of immediate crises foreign aid is good). Rather, I wonder whether long-term forms of aid can unintentionally perpetuate the very conditions they are intended to eliminate.
One of my biggest questions is whether continuously providing free resources can undermine the development of self-sufficient local economies.
Consider what happens when international organizations repeatedly distribute free goods, food, medical supplies and other necessities.
What happens to local businesses that sell those same products?
For example, imagine a local entrepreneur who starts a business selling mosquito nets. They invest their savings, purchase inventory, hire employees, and try to build a sustainable business. Then an international organization arrives and distributes thousands of mosquito nets for free.
Consumers understandably choose the free alternative. The entrepreneur struggles to compete, potentially loses their business, and employees lose their jobs.
The immediate intervention might have helped people obtain mosquito nets, but could it also have undermined the development of a local market that might eventually have supplied those same people?
The same concern applies to food assistance. If large quantities of free food enter a local market, local farmers may find themselves competing against artificially cheap or free alternatives. Their incomes could fall, reducing their incentive and ability to continue producing food.
I think this raises an important question: Are we helping people become economically independent, or are we unintentionally making it harder for them to develop independent sources of income?
Another concern is whether prolonged assistance can create a culture of dependency.
If communities become accustomed to receiving food, medical supplies, infrastructure, and other necessities from foreign organizations, what happens to the incentives to develop domestic solutions?
Could people and institutions gradually become less inclined to solve problems independently because external organizations are expected to intervene?
Quite controversially, I want to be careful here but is it possible that foreign aid may be making Africans lazy and unwilling to work despite living in poverty?
Check this story on this Twitter post here: https://x.com/UltraDane/status/2110789805730844858
I am questioning whether the structure of aid itself can produce learned helplessness or institutional dependence.
Furthermore, if a government knows that international donors will repeatedly finance malaria prevention, healthcare, food assistance, and other essential services, does that reduce political pressure to prioritize those services in their own budget?
Could foreign aid inadvertently allow governments to avoid responsibilities that should belong to them?
Why should international donors continually bear such a substantial portion of the costs of addressing preventable diseases and other domestic problems?
Take malaria prevention as an example.
Malaria is a major public health problem in sub-Saharan Africa. Insecticide-treated mosquito nets are relatively inexpensive, and distributing them can prevent infections and save lives.
But why does so much of the financing have to come from international donors?
Shouldn't governments in malaria-endemic countries be making malaria prevention a central priority in their own national budgets?
According to ChatGPT, the 2001 Abuja Declaration committed African governments to allocating at least 15% of their national budgets to healthcare. Yet WHO data indicate that average government health spending in its African Region was only around 7.1% of total government spending in 2022.
This raises questions about government priorities, accountability, and political incentives.
Shouldn't African governments contribute more to malaria control?
Nevertheless shouldn't international assistance be structured to encourage governments to gradually assume greater financial responsibility?
I worry that an arrangement in which donors continuously finance essential services without a credible transition plan risks becoming sort of permanent.
Another major problem is institutional accountability.
Even when donors provide money with good intentions, there is no guarantee that it reaches the people who need it.
Food assistance, for example, can be stolen, diverted, or sold by corrupt government officials, military groups, or intermediaries before reaching its intended recipients.
According to ChatGPT, in 2023, the United States suspended food assistance in Ethiopia after discovering widespread diversion of humanitarian food aid. A February 2025 USAID Inspector General report subsequently documented significant weaknesses in oversight, monitoring, and incident reporting.
This raises an uncomfortable question: How much of the money we donate actually reaches its intended beneficiaries?
And more importantly, what consequences do organizations face when they fail?
Should organizations that repeatedly fail to monitor their spending continue receiving donations without substantial scrutiny?
I also wonder whether the incentives of aid organizations are properly aligned with the outcomes they claim to pursue.
An organization might measure its success by how much money it raises, how many programs it operates, how many supplies it distributes, or how many people it claims to reach.
But are these necessarily good measures of long-term success?
What if an organization distributes millions of dollars in assistance but contributes little to improving the underlying economic conditions that created the need for assistance?
What if its continued existence depends, at least partly, on the persistence of the problem it was established to solve?
Organizations can develop institutional incentives to maintain their funding, staff, and operations, even when their long-term impact is difficult to demonstrate.
Shouldn't successful development assistance ultimately make itself unnecessary ?
Furthermore, one thing that particularly confuses me is the cost-effectiveness of malaria prevention.
A mosquito net might cost approximately $3-5 to purchase. Yet GiveWell estimates that distributing insecticide-treated nets through its supported programs costs approximately $5,000 per death averted in its current analysis.
Why is the difference so substantial?
I think the example illustrates a broader question about aid efficiency.
Why can't malaria-endemic governments establish more sustainable domestic systems for purchasing and distributing these relatively inexpensive nets (would save on distribution, transportation, staffing, monitoring, and administrative expenses most probably).
Why most international organizations continually raise money to fund interventions that governments should arguably be able to provide themselves?
And if we are spending thousands of dollars to avert one death, should we also consider whether some of that money could be invested in strengthening local healthcare systems, domestic manufacturing, distribution systems or government capacity?
Perhaps we should stop distributing nets. I wonder whether we should be evaluating these interventions by whether they contribute to a system that can eventually operate without foreign assistance.
What is the ultimate goal of foreign aid?
Is it continually provide food, medical supplies, mosquito nets, vaccinations, and other neccessities to people living in poverty?
Or is it to help create societies where these necessities can be sustainably provided through domestic institutions, businesses, employment, and economic development?
If the latter is the objective, shouldn't we be paying considerably more attention to whether out interventions contribute to that outcome?
There seems to be a difference between alleviating poverty and eliminating the underlying conditions that perpetuate poverty.
For example, providing food to a hungry family can be valuable. However, there is the whole saying of "Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day; teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime". Helping create an environment where that family can earn enough money to purchase its own food is obviously the best and most sustainable solution.
Distributing free mosquito nets can save lives, but building domestic capacity to manufacture, purchase and distribute them might offer a more sustainable long-term solution.
I feel like these approaches might be mutually exclusive. I worry that the immediate, measurable benefits of aid can overshadow the less visible economic and institutional consequences.
I'm not necessarily advocating for eliminating foreign aid. Emergency assistance during TEMPORARY issues famines, natural disasters, epidemics, and conflicts seems particularly difficult to argue against.
However, issues that seem to have almost be rooted in a sort of PERMANENCY like these vaccinations, malaria prevention, and some other issues from GiveWell seem more problematic to me.
I wonder whether effective altruism should primarily focus on economic development (supporting entrepreneurship, domestic businesses, infrastructure, education and employment) and institutional development (strengthening local governments, improving accountability, reducing corruption, and developing sustainable public services). Additionally, I think its acceptable for effective altruism to support in moments of immediate crises (e.g. natural disasters).
Could we prioritize programs that build local capacity rather than simply distributing free resources?
Could international organizations establish measurable transition goals, whereby governments gradually assume more financial responsibility?
Could donors require stronger independent auditing and monitoring before continuing to fund organizations?
Could we invest in local businesses and entrepreneurs instead of creating parallel economies dominated by international NGOs and donor-funded organizations?
And perhaps most importantly, should some interventions have explicit exit strategies?
Are we solving poverty, or managing it indefinitely?
I think effective altruism should be willing to question whether interventions that produce immediate positive outcomes might also create negative long-term incentives.
If an organization saves lives today but contributes to a system in which communities and governments remain dependent on external assistance indefinitely, how should we evaluate its overall impact?
Is it possible that some forms of aid are inadvertently perpetuating the conditions they are intended to eliminate?
And if so, how should we distinguish between aid that genuinely empowers people and aid that merely maintains a permanent cycle of dependency?
Ultimately, shouldn't the goal of foreign aid be to make itself unnecessary?