The very concept of human rights rests upon the immutable foundation of our shared humanity. This humanity is evident in the unique, unrepeatable, inimitable, and irreplaceable nature of each and every human life. No human being can be replicated; each and every human life exhibits an individuality that renders its replacement impossible. Consequently, each and every human life is distinctly and inestimably valuable. - Rehumanize International
I'm Lauren Pope, and I'm the Executive Director of Rehumanize International. I'm here to introduce you to the basics of the Consistent Life Ethic and answer any questions you might have about it as an ethical system.
I came here primarily because I strongly believe that the CLE provides a framework for AI alignment and human flourishing in a post-AGI world.
However, I'll be upfront in saying that this ideology is not without controversy. Because we believe that all human beings are entitled to living a life free from violence, we oppose all manner of violent attacks on human beings including: abortion, the death penalty, war, euthanasia, police brutality, dragon drones, induced famines and embryo destruction.
And I know that by being so blunt, I've already made some people find an exit, but I think it's important to give you the full scope and why being explicitly pro-human even at the earliest stages is so critical for our species survival.
Many acts of state sanctioned violence are justified using the reasoning that the human in question lacks the capacity required for full personhood. This might be because they are too young, too old, too sick, or too violent.
Regardless, we have measured them and found them lacking in some critical way that allows them to be harmed for some other larger good.
The problem with basing rights on capacity instead of humanity in this current moment is that we are racing headlong into a situation in which some other, shall we say, lifeform, has much greater capacity than our own.
Are we too unintelligent to matter in the grand cosmos? There are those who'd argue that case.
I reject it. Instead, the CLE claims that our humanity is the defining feature that determines our value, independent of any practical or contemplative functionality.
We matter because we are human. It is wrong to kill us because we are human. That is enough.
It is also the value that advanced AI systems must hold absolutely if we are to be safe from harm. If our value is based at all on our capacity, either globally or individually, we are at risk of a more "valuable" system finding us disposable. A utilitarian calculus of our worth must not enter the equation. The CLE rejects consequentialism altogether, and instead advocates for a cohesive, expansive call for non-violence.
For 15 years, my organization has been screaming from the rooftops that our value cannot be derived from our abilities. This is the last chance for that message to be heard before we are all measured and found wanting.
AMA