Hide table of contents

We have contact details and can send emails to 1500 students and former students who've received hard-cover copies of HPMOR (and possibly Human Compatible and/or The Precipice) because they've won international or Russian olympiads in maths, computer science, physics, biology, or chemistry.

This includes over 60 IMO and IOI medalists.

This is a pool of potentially extremely talented people, many of whom have read HPMOR.

I don't have the time to do anything with them, and people in the Russian-speaking EA community are all busy with other things.

The only thing that ever happened was an email sent to some kids still in high school about the Atlas Fellowship, and a couple of them became fellows.

I think it could be very valuable to alignment-pill these people. I think for most researchers who understand AI x-risk well enough and can speak Russian, even manually going through IMO and IOI medalists, sending those who seem more promising a tl;dr of x-risk and offering to schedule a call would be a marginally better use of their time than most technical alignment research they could be otherwise doing, because it plausibly adds highly capable researchers.

If you understand AI x-risk, are smart, have good epistemics, speak Russian, and want to have that ball, please DM me on LW or elsewhere.

To everyone else, feel free to make suggestions.

32

0
0

Reactions

0
0
Comments9
Sorted by Click to highlight new comments since:

We also have 6k more copies (18k hard-cover books) left. We have no idea what to do with them. Suggestions are welcome.

Here's a map of Russian libraries that requested copies of HPMOR, and we've sent 2126 copies to:

Sending HPMOR to random libraries is cool, but I hope someone comes up with better ways of spending the books.

I'm still a bit confused - that's a lot of books, especially since they are all in Russian! And 18k hardcover! I'm a bit more credulous about the impact of such an effort than others - actual insight in the books is less important than having a fun attraction to adjacent ideas. It's worked before: the growth of less wrong may be partly attributable to this and analogously some films, eg The China Syndrome, film/sci-fi novel nuclear doom conceptions may have had significant impact in molding the attitudes of the public.

But still that's a lot of books! And if I understand correctly, with no connection to the ones which were (or weren't?) successfully distributed by the 28k in grant money, before the project ended.

Why so many? What fraction of original copies made have been successfully distributed? I understand that this wasn't from grant money, I'm just curious about the story here is all. 

Edit: saw this. So apparently 68k originally. Wow! 

I'm confused about this discrepancy between LessWrong and EA Forum. (Feedback is welcome!)

Is this the outcome of the 28 thousand dollar grant detailed here

To summarise, six years ago you recieved a 28 thousand dollar grant, awarded people a bunch of copies of harry potter fanfiction that was available online for free and was only tangentially related to EA, and then never actually followed up on any of the people you sent the book to?

This does not look like a cost effective use of grant money. I assume the vast majority of the recipients either didn't read it, or read it for the amusement without caring about the underlying message, which was not very heavily sold. 

Nope. The grant you linked to was not in any way connected to me or the books I've printed. A couple of years ago, (edit: in 2019) I was surprised to learn about that grant; the claim that there was coordination with "the team behind the highly successful Russian printing of HPMOR" (which is me/us) is false. (I don't think the recipients of the grant you're referencing even have a way to follow up with the people they gave books. Also, as IMO 2020 was cancelled, they should’ve returned most of the grant.)

EA money was not involved in printing the books that I have.

We've started sending books to olympiad winners in December 2022. All of the copies we've sent have been explicitly requested, often together with copies of The Precipice and/or Human Compatible, sometimes after having already read it (usually due to my previous efforts), usually after having seen endorsements by popular science people and literary critics.

I have a very different model of how HPMOR affects this specific audience and I think this is a lot more valuable than selling the books[1] -> donating anywhere else.

  1. ^

    (we can't actually sell these books due to copyright-related constraints.)

Upvoted because I'm glad you answered the question (and didn't use EA grant money for this).

Disagreevoted because as an IMO medalist, I neither think science olympiad medalists are really such a useful audience, nor do I see any value in disseminating said fanfiction to potential alignment researchers.

Speaking as an IMO medalist who partially got into AI safety because of reading HPMOR 10 years ago, I think this plan is extremely reasonable

Anecdotally, approximately everyone who's now working on AI safety with Russian origins got into it because of HPMOR. Just a couple of days ago, an IOI gold medalist reached out to me, they've been going through ARENA.

HPMOR tends to make people with that kind of background act more on trying to save the world. It also gives some intuitive sense for some related stuff (up to "oh, like the mirror from HPMOR?"), but this is a lot less central than giving people the ~EA values and making them actually do stuff.

(Plus, at this point, the book is well-known enough in some circles that some % of future Russian ML researchers would be a lot easier to alignment-pill and persuade to not work on something that might kill everyone or prompt other countries to build something that kills everyone.

Like, the largest Russian broker decided to celebrate the New Year by advertising HPMOR and citing Yudkowsky.)

I'm not sure how universal this is- the kind of Russian kid who is into math/computer science is the kind of kid who would often be into the HPMOR aesthetics- but it seems to work.

I think many past IMO/IOI medalists are generally very capable and can help, and it's worth looking at the list of them and reaching out to people who've read HPMOR (and possibly The Precipice/Human Compatible) and getting them to work on AI safety.

This looks like the second time in two months you posted harsh but inaccurate criticism of a group based on confusing them with a different group. I suggest in the future you put more effort into understanding the people you are criticizing.

Curated and popular this week
Relevant opportunities