Epistemic status: Speculation from two decently informed advocates armed with anecdata.
Note on process: After having some version of this conversation several times and saying, “we should probably write about this publicly,” we took the less heroic route: we recorded one of our conversations, fed the transcript into an LLM, and then substantially revised the structure, substance, and framing ourselves. We will not be sharing the transcript, as it is in...
I want to start by noting that I am amazed and somewhat in awe of what's been accomplished by the EA animal welfare movement. I am enthusiastically supportive of all campaigns that make living and dying conditions less bad for farmed animals.
I worked on such campaigns for almost 20 years, and I'm proud of that work.
That said, I do think it's a strategic error that the EA animal movement has so thoroughly moved on from advocacy for animal liberation and diet change.&n...
The swarm has made me feel AI risk in my bones for the first time
Until the Hugging Face / OpenAI swarm thing, I think I deep down felt pretty skeptical that extinction or serious loss of control scenarios were plausible in the next few years.
I’ve been lurking on LessWrong for years, and I remember being freaked out by Yudkowsky’s ‘List of Lethalities’ in 2022, and thinking that this did seem intellectually convincing, and maybe I should do something about it. But it didn...
Its great to see the number of meetups flourishing. As an "old geezer" I felt perfectly at home at the meetup organised in London last week, which was well attended and buzzing with interesting conversations. The link between the online community turning into a real community (which can reinforce giving behaviour etc) is really powerful in building strength and depth in effective altruism. If organisers of the events could drop quick meetup reports here we could build the knowledge base of what is working and what isn't, what meetups could do etc it would probably also inspire people to start more.
Certainly i am inspired to start a slightly older group in London, with a link to and expertise from the core movement, which would provide two way learning - how to engage with the older mainstream, non-academic community, and start to normalise "making the most difference possible" as a normal, worthwhile thing to do in the mainstream community, and be inspired by an amazing community of young people who are doing exactly that. Thoughts/comments would be appreciated.
Just a thought - a huge number of people get involved in small charities for "self actualisation"/ego-enhancement and do so incredibly ineffectively, with the whole thing turning into an opportunity for self promotion which achieves very little at all - effective or not. Effective Altruists have a real opportunity to offer consulting services and provide guiding lights to doing more and doing it better on that particular cause, and in so doing gently introduce new (highly effective) causes to a broad cross section of the population. For example offering to provide xx hours of consultancy for $xx per hour (to be directly donated to your chosen cause) would:
Thoughts/comments would be appreciated.
Yes, the consulting role is interesting. I guess that to perform consulting, it's most important to have good credentials so our Oxford researchers might be able to contribute here. Using a model where consultancy fees are donated to a great cause seems like a great model to me.