Thank you for this excellent, constructive blog on a systems approach to the complex solution of diet change. I look forward to reading more about your study and peer support. I've ordered the book by Damon Centola (Change: How to make big things happen). In a recent episode, the most popular podcast on climate called Outrage and Optimism, talked about a layer cake of reasons to take climate action from science (data), ethics, financial incentives, health and so forth. They also suggested Centola-type research pointing to research which shows that evidence is important but not effective on its own in changing people's minds; it is not sufficient. Most people need evidence plus social signaling.
I think a holistic, systems approach needs to be applied to the problem as well as the solution (your blog focused on the much needed latter point on how to effectively acheive lasting diet change).
Starting with the problem we need to include the benefits of animal protection campaigns for animals but also the climate, health, reduced pandemic risk and food security. A group of us put together the www.BeyondCageFree.org campaign and open letter to ask the EA community to consider pivoting to plant-based food system change as the main priority due to our current broken food system causing not only unprecedented animal exploitation and suffering, but also, in an age of polycrisis, the climate emergency, health issues, pandemic risk and food security concerns.
In 2026, the first study on energy use in the US by data centers: after a steady or flat use of electricity over the last couple of decades, projected increases in the number of data centers due to AI and crypto could spike “power sector CO2 emissions by up to 28% relative to a future with no data center growth” by 2030 - in just 4 years! Companies like xAI, Open AI and Anthropic are shifting investments toward off-grid or on-site fossil fuel power to bypass utility delays. They are largely investing if gas turbines which will increase greenhouse gas emissions and create stranded assets: a decades long dependence on fossil fuels just as we are heading towards climate tipping points and transgressing other planetary boundaries.
According to the United Nations Environment Program's recent report Limiting Overshoot - Navigating exceedance of 1.5°C and pathways towards return, we are overshooting our climate commitments of 1.5-2 degrees Celsius in the next 3-5 years. We need to move away from fossil fuels to renewables and urgent shift to a plant-based food system! The Beyond Cage-Free open letter similarly makes the point that investing in welfare tech and cage-free facilities are long-term infrastructure investments in new housing, equipment, and farm retrofits which could become stranded assets. "Such long-lived infrastructure inadvertently strengthens economic and political incentives to sustain egg production throughout the asset’s lifespan, making our future transition to plant-based systems slower and more expensive. Investing in cage-free factory farms leaves us with stranded assets due to the worsening climate crisis and land and water overuse. Continued investment in cage-free infrastructure risks locking philanthropy into stranded assets designed to perpetuate animal agriculture for decades."
In terms of solutions, campaigns need to be evaluated holistically and systemically from a polycrisis point of view. We need to consider not only the benefits to animals but the multiple costs to the climate, health, pandemic risk and food security of different animal welfare campaigns when compared to the win-win plant-based or diet change campaigns.
In addition to your prize idea, it would be great if we could bring together all of us concerned about animals to sit down with our natural allies working on philosophy and ethics, climate, health, pandemic risk, labour, and food security as well as funders like @Coefficient Giving and develop optimal complex systems approaches to diet change and food system change. In @Barbara Buril's comment she refers to the work of the Ayni Institute and Robert Gass’s Wheel of Change focusing on three domains: Hearts & Minds, Behavior and Structures. Your COM-B model and these models of social change are excellent ways of considering agents and structures. It'd be great to also include Kate Raworth's Doughnut Economics and George Monbiot's Regenesis books to root our systems work on social systems in the natural environment.
Thank you @Vanille Victoria Ashkanovna for your inspiring plant-based food system change work in France and Europe. I think it's a great opportunity for animal protection and environmental and health movements to get together and ask @Holden Karnofsky and other donors at Anthropic to use their LLMs to develops a complex systems approach for helping animal, climate, environmental, health, and food security advocates in plant-based food system change. We need to move way Beyond Cage-Free. We can do it together!!
Definitely a holistic systems approach is needed to help animals, climate and environmental protection, reduced pandemic risk, food security and health. It's a win-win. Thanks for your inspiring work in Brazil.
Hi @Bruno Monteiro Do you see small wins in plant-based meal replacement as motivating. @Naman Dedhia and Chef Jaya went into multiple schools in Bhutan and made the menu entiredly vegan and these are documented in 2 Vlog series (one in April and one from last month) on Plant Based Treaty's IG and YouTube. Chef Jaya says people are so open to plant-based, more than we might think. She make delicious, nutritious and cheaper meals. I think it's these kind of programs that could be scaled AMA: Lewis Bollard, Open Philanthropy
@Soili Kasanen 🔸 thanks for sharing your wonderful story of awareness and evolution. I too went through a buying cage-free phase for years. I became a vegetarian and only in 2004 a vegan after I learned about the milk indsutry's spearation of calves and their killing. I assumed before that animals weren't killed (somehow) and never really thought about it from the animals perpective what their journey was. If someone told me I'd change right away. Students at Queen U who were followers of Gary Francione called me out and I then researched dairy milk and changed. I'm grateful to the students! :)
Thanks @Valezca for your plant-based food advocacy in Mexico. Mexico is a great opporunity with a climate and food conscious President that just shifted the national food guidelines to 92% plant based but this needs to be implemented in schools, unis, hospitals and other institutions. They need a national action plan for plant-based food. AMA: Lewis Bollard, Open Philanthropy your help here would be momentous.
Thanks Lia, you're passion, knowledge and dedication are infectious. Thank you for publishing a blog for In Defense of Animals (IDA). Living in the Bay Area as you do you can see the focus on welfare tech and I know how difficult it is when the metric should be reducing the number of animals in the food system and not optimizing factory farms for efficiency and impossibly welfare - as no person would want to live in a factory farm and have machines breed, confine, feed and kill you.
Thanks @Jack White 🔹 for the good references. Regarding the second the authors conclude there isn't great data yet but there is great interest in recent years which is encouraging. They write: "we observe many fruitful collaborations between researchers and advocacy organizations, as shown by the large number of nonprofit white papers in our sample." and "many promising designs and interventions still await rigorous evaluation. For instance, no study that met our criteria evaluated extended contact with farm animals [144], manipulations to the price of meat [145], activating moral and/or physical disgust [146], watching popular media such as the Simpsons episode “Lisa the Vegetarian” [147] or the movie Babe [148], and many categories of choice architecture intervention [149]." UK's Project Slingshot is working on the "activiating moral and/or physical disgust" criteria and is attempting measurement. AMA: Lewis Bollard, Program Director of Farm Animal Welfare at OpenPhil is providing support for this approach.
The found a couple of choice architecture studies useful. The psychology and persuasion studies not so convincing yet.
With respect to your first reference, I'll take a look and speak to PETA's White Paper authors (Amber Canavan and Prof. Vasile Stanescu). My own take right now is there are multiple atrocities in factory farms and animals are bred and exploited without their consent. None of us would want to replace ourselves for them because in the western tradition the individual is sacrosanct and has rights. Applying the Golden Rule, we need to treat others as we'd like to be treated. For me it's not about weighing and shifting welfare pains but being treated like a subject-of-a-life with animal rights. This suggests we pivot beyond cage-free to plant based food system change as the main priority. Thanks again for references.
I'm heartened by you and your team at your NGO work on plant-based food demonstrations in communities, cafes, and restaurants. There is a way forward. Turkey has experienced climate changes that have been devastating to wildlife and farmed animals plus the earthquake. You've first hand witnessed this and rescued dogs, chickens and other animals. It's so important to work to mitigate climate change through diet change. AMA: Lewis Bollard, Open Philanthropy it's so important to support people and groups in the frontlines.
Thank you for this excellent, constructive blog on a systems approach to the complex solution of diet change. I look forward to reading more about your study and peer support. I've ordered the book by Damon Centola (Change: How to make big things happen). In a recent episode, the most popular podcast on climate called Outrage and Optimism, talked about a layer cake of reasons to take climate action from science (data), ethics, financial incentives, health and so forth. They also suggested Centola-type research pointing to research which shows that evidence is important but not effective on its own in changing people's minds; it is not sufficient. Most people need evidence plus social signaling.
I think a holistic, systems approach needs to be applied to the problem as well as the solution (your blog focused on the much needed latter point on how to effectively acheive lasting diet change).
Starting with the problem we need to include the benefits of animal protection campaigns for animals but also the climate, health, reduced pandemic risk and food security. A group of us put together the www.BeyondCageFree.org campaign and open letter to ask the EA community to consider pivoting to plant-based food system change as the main priority due to our current broken food system causing not only unprecedented animal exploitation and suffering, but also, in an age of polycrisis, the climate emergency, health issues, pandemic risk and food security concerns.
In 2026, the first study on energy use in the US by data centers: after a steady or flat use of electricity over the last couple of decades, projected increases in the number of data centers due to AI and crypto could spike “power sector CO2 emissions by up to 28% relative to a future with no data center growth” by 2030 - in just 4 years! Companies like xAI, Open AI and Anthropic are shifting investments toward off-grid or on-site fossil fuel power to bypass utility delays. They are largely investing if gas turbines which will increase greenhouse gas emissions and create stranded assets: a decades long dependence on fossil fuels just as we are heading towards climate tipping points and transgressing other planetary boundaries.
According to the United Nations Environment Program's recent report Limiting Overshoot - Navigating exceedance of 1.5°C and pathways towards return, we are overshooting our climate commitments of 1.5-2 degrees Celsius in the next 3-5 years. We need to move away from fossil fuels to renewables and urgent shift to a plant-based food system! The Beyond Cage-Free open letter similarly makes the point that investing in welfare tech and cage-free facilities are long-term infrastructure investments in new housing, equipment, and farm retrofits which could become stranded assets. "Such long-lived infrastructure inadvertently strengthens economic and political incentives to sustain egg production throughout the asset’s lifespan, making our future transition to plant-based systems slower and more expensive. Investing in cage-free factory farms leaves us with stranded assets due to the worsening climate crisis and land and water overuse. Continued investment in cage-free infrastructure risks locking philanthropy into stranded assets designed to perpetuate animal agriculture for decades."
In terms of solutions, campaigns need to be evaluated holistically and systemically from a polycrisis point of view. We need to consider not only the benefits to animals but the multiple costs to the climate, health, pandemic risk and food security of different animal welfare campaigns when compared to the win-win plant-based or diet change campaigns.
In addition to your prize idea, it would be great if we could bring together all of us concerned about animals to sit down with our natural allies working on philosophy and ethics, climate, health, pandemic risk, labour, and food security as well as funders like @Coefficient Giving and develop optimal complex systems approaches to diet change and food system change. In @Barbara Buril's comment she refers to the work of the Ayni Institute and Robert Gass’s Wheel of Change focusing on three domains: Hearts & Minds, Behavior and Structures. Your COM-B model and these models of social change are excellent ways of considering agents and structures. It'd be great to also include Kate Raworth's Doughnut Economics and George Monbiot's Regenesis books to root our systems work on social systems in the natural environment.
I did a podcast with Rayane at Vegan Report on Beyond Cage-Free in case you have a chance to listen: https://rss.com/podcasts/veganreport/3205830/
Thank you @Vanille Victoria Ashkanovna for your inspiring plant-based food system change work in France and Europe. I think it's a great opportunity for animal protection and environmental and health movements to get together and ask @Holden Karnofsky and other donors at Anthropic to use their LLMs to develops a complex systems approach for helping animal, climate, environmental, health, and food security advocates in plant-based food system change. We need to move way Beyond Cage-Free. We can do it together!!
Definitely a holistic systems approach is needed to help animals, climate and environmental protection, reduced pandemic risk, food security and health. It's a win-win. Thanks for your inspiring work in Brazil.
Hi @Bruno Monteiro
Do you see small wins in plant-based meal replacement as motivating. @Naman Dedhia and Chef Jaya went into multiple schools in Bhutan and made the menu entiredly vegan and these are documented in 2 Vlog series (one in April and one from last month) on Plant Based Treaty's IG and YouTube. Chef Jaya says people are so open to plant-based, more than we might think. She make delicious, nutritious and cheaper meals. I think it's these kind of programs that could be scaled AMA: Lewis Bollard, Open Philanthropy
@Soili Kasanen 🔸 thanks for sharing your wonderful story of awareness and evolution. I too went through a buying cage-free phase for years. I became a vegetarian and only in 2004 a vegan after I learned about the milk indsutry's spearation of calves and their killing. I assumed before that animals weren't killed (somehow) and never really thought about it from the animals perpective what their journey was. If someone told me I'd change right away. Students at Queen U who were followers of Gary Francione called me out and I then researched dairy milk and changed. I'm grateful to the students! :)
Thanks @Valezca for your plant-based food advocacy in Mexico. Mexico is a great opporunity with a climate and food conscious President that just shifted the national food guidelines to 92% plant based but this needs to be implemented in schools, unis, hospitals and other institutions. They need a national action plan for plant-based food. AMA: Lewis Bollard, Open Philanthropy your help here would be momentous.
Thanks Lia, you're passion, knowledge and dedication are infectious. Thank you for publishing a blog for In Defense of Animals (IDA). Living in the Bay Area as you do you can see the focus on welfare tech and I know how difficult it is when the metric should be reducing the number of animals in the food system and not optimizing factory farms for efficiency and impossibly welfare - as no person would want to live in a factory farm and have machines breed, confine, feed and kill you.
Thanks @Jack White 🔹 for the good references. Regarding the second the authors conclude there isn't great data yet but there is great interest in recent years which is encouraging. They write: "we observe many fruitful collaborations between researchers and advocacy organizations, as shown by the large number of nonprofit white papers in our sample." and "many promising designs and interventions still await rigorous evaluation. For instance, no study that met our criteria evaluated extended contact with farm animals [144], manipulations to the price of meat [145], activating moral and/or physical disgust [146], watching popular media such as the Simpsons episode “Lisa the Vegetarian” [147] or the movie Babe [148], and many categories of choice architecture intervention [149]." UK's Project Slingshot is working on the "activiating moral and/or physical disgust" criteria and is attempting measurement. AMA: Lewis Bollard, Program Director of Farm Animal Welfare at OpenPhil is providing support for this approach.
The found a couple of choice architecture studies useful. The psychology and persuasion studies not so convincing yet.
With respect to your first reference, I'll take a look and speak to PETA's White Paper authors (Amber Canavan and Prof. Vasile Stanescu). My own take right now is there are multiple atrocities in factory farms and animals are bred and exploited without their consent. None of us would want to replace ourselves for them because in the western tradition the individual is sacrosanct and has rights. Applying the Golden Rule, we need to treat others as we'd like to be treated. For me it's not about weighing and shifting welfare pains but being treated like a subject-of-a-life with animal rights. This suggests we pivot beyond cage-free to plant based food system change as the main priority. Thanks again for references.
I'm heartened by you and your team at your NGO work on plant-based food demonstrations in communities, cafes, and restaurants. There is a way forward. Turkey has experienced climate changes that have been devastating to wildlife and farmed animals plus the earthquake. You've first hand witnessed this and rescued dogs, chickens and other animals. It's so important to work to mitigate climate change through diet change. AMA: Lewis Bollard, Open Philanthropy it's so important to support people and groups in the frontlines.