All of BrianTan's Comments + Replies

The main URL didn't work for me, but the backup did. This was fun and useful; it helped me better understand what these different farming systems are like!

Minor thing, but I don't remember Dustin being portrayed much in The Social Network? Do you mean Eduardo Saverin?

2
Eevee🔹
Yeah, he is. He was played by Joseph Mazzello.
3
Joseph_Chu
Oh, woops, I totally confused the two. My bad.

Thanks for linking this! I don't see anything under "Updated notes by me, Remmelt:" though

4
Remmelt
Ah, it's meant to be the footnotes. Let me edit that to be less confusing.

Cool initiative! (Btw the last sentence is cut off / doesn't have a link)

4
gergo
Thanks for flagging, fixed it now!

Minor question: What's the For Humanity’s AI Safety Special documentary? Is there a way to watch it already? I can't find it online.

5
sammyboiz🔸
I forgot to hyperlink. Thanks for pointing this out.

I'm not from LTFF but I believe you can apply for funding with an end date past Aug 31! The application form now mentions it's only the EAIF that has that restriction.

@calebp @Linch 

  1. Can someone from LTFF confirm if this restriction (that the grant period should end on or before Aug 31, 2025) will be set for all applications in this Q1 grant round? (When I first saw the note referenced above around December, I thought it would lift before the Feb 15 deadline, but it seems like it's not going to be lifted by then?)
  2. I also have the same question as Pip above!
9
calebp
We have actually just managed to lift that restriction for the ltff, the application form and website should be updated to reflect this in the next week. This means that no balance will need to be returned after August if the project is still active.

Thanks for these helpful points! Minor note: Did you mean Schmidt Futures and not Smith Futures?

3
EffectiveAdvocate🔸
Yes! 

Thanks for the update! I appreciate that decisions will be communicated within 1.5 months of the application deadline.

Btw, this URL (https://funds.effectivealtruism.org/funds/far-future/apply) you link to leads to "Page not found".

4
Linch
Appreciate it! @BrianTan and others, feel free to use this thread as a way to report other issues and bugs with the website/grant round announcement. 
4
calebp
Thanks. Should now be fixed!

Hey Leo, sorry for the late reply, but thanks for explaining and updating the post!

I understand that you and Juana are funded as national coordinators, but I still think including staff costs in the event budget would give a better picture. Maybe you could estimate the time you and Juana spent on the event to calculate the staff cost and add that to the budget?

I think the cost per attendee would be more realistic and helpful if it included staff costs, or if it was shown both with and without staff costs. This could give others a more realistic idea of wha... (read more)

Congrats Leo, Juana, and the rest of the team on the event! I have a minor question about the writeup: It seems that the budget and cost per attendee do not include the team's salaries, and I assume there were salaries/staff costs incurred. Are there reasons for not including staff costs in the calculations? (I noticed that this was also the case for EAGxLatAm 2024, though that was organized by a different team.)

I think including staff costs provides a better picture of the money spent organizing these events. Of course, there may be considerations I'm not... (read more)

3
Juana Maria Huisa 🔸
Important note Brian Tan. Thank you very much!
2
Leo Arruda
Hi Brian, thanks for noticing it, in our case the reason is that Juana and I are currently funded as national coordinators, I've now added it to the reasons for having a low cost. 

Hi Dawn, thanks for your interest in donating to EA Philippines! I'm unsure if I understood you correctly, but EA PH's minimum funding goal on Manifund is $500, as the team would appreciate any amount of funding. So I think if your donation is at least $400, then the project would indeed be funded, and you wouldn't need to be refunded. Let me know if this answers your concern!

2
Dawn Drescher
Oh, great! I interpreted “This is an offer to donate this amount to the project on the condition that it eventually becomes active” to mean that the project might not become active for any number of reasons, only one of them being the funding goal.

Hey James, sorry for the late reply, but thanks for the feedback! 

Here are the averages across groups by country for each of the group measures:

It would be time-consuming to show how the group measures have changed by country across groups surveys, and some questions in the 2022 census weren’t asked previously, so I hope the above is useful enough for you.

I can share the number of groups founded per country by year since 2011 here though (for groups still currently active):

I only included countries with a minimum of 3 groups that filled out the 2022 c... (read more)

3
James Herbert
Beaut, thanks very much!

Hey Manuel, sorry for the late reply, but thanks for your comment!

I agree it would be better for the results of EA surveys (including this one) to be published earlier. The reason the census results came out in June was because: 

  1. In January-March, I had to prioritize other tasks/projects instead of analyzing and writing the census results
  2. Analyzing and writing the census results took longer than I expected

We'll try to publish the results for this year's census a bit earlier.

I agree that it seems good for EA to have a career-focused pledge, and I wrote up a similar idea here on the Forum two years ago, which had mixed feedback then. I think some people thought it was a bad idea because of the "maximizing" language in the pledge's name and the post though, but they may still be sympathetic to the idea of a career-focused pledge. I now think that a "do the most good" pledge is not an ideal name, and I've updated the post to say this.

One difference between your pledge idea and mine is that yours doesn't sound like a lifetime pled... (read more)

The link to the Substack page at the top doesn't work for me for some reason, even if it works on LessWrong. Maybe it's a bug. Maybe you could get the link to work somehow?

Answer by BrianTan10
0
0

In case you haven't seen it, the Resource Centre has advice on doing 1-1's! It also links some resources on 1-1's, including the Global Challenges Project's guide.

I see, yeah you might get better attendance for social events when the group is more established and has more regular members!

No worries, and I'll keep an eye on it! Sorry, I missed out on your last question. During our first year, I think we viewed EA Philippines as a serious organization trying to market EA via well-run events (i.e. with speakers), rather than as a small, tight-knit community. Moreover, it was only in November that we started to feel we had enough regular attendees (i.e. 15-20) to organize a socials.

Looking back, we could have done one or two more social meetups that year. I only say one or two because I think other types of events (especially discussions of EA... (read more)

1
Mike Pool
Thanks again Brian! Again, quite helpful to hear your perspective :D We had a bit of a strikeout with our first social meetup last week with 0 attendees aside from the organizers XD It may be this was a fluke, but it also may be that until the group's better established and members have built up relationships with each other, more structured structured meetings will draw more people in. We'll see what happens at our discussion group next week! :D

In case you (or others) didn't know, you can find the top Shortform posts every month or every year at https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/allPosts, below the list of top posts. (There doesn't seem to be a way to see the top ones all time though.)

Hey Mike, thanks for the kind feedback, and thanks for helping EA South Korea!  I can answer your questions:

  1. That $2,400 was via CEA's group support funding. You're correct though that the link is now different and is now here. 

    I now work for CEA as a group support contractor, and I process group support funding applications. EA South Korea can apply for group support funding from CEA for any expenses within our common expense guidelines. 
  2. Yes, I did speak. I don't remember it well, but I think I gave an intro to EA and EA Philippines. I may h
... (read more)
1
Mike Pool
Thanks for answering my questions and the links! The additional info is much appreciated :D We'll be submitting an application for group support funding in the coming weeks, so keep an eye out for it! Mind if I bug you to answer my 5th question too? We're planning on having a monthly social gathering, so I'm wondering if you found there to be any downsides to having them more regularly. 5. Why did you have so few general social meetups?

Cool to see this is happening - when is the deadline for people to apply?

3
Matej_Vrzala
Hi Brian, thanks for asking. We do have a place for  20 to 40 people.  We don't have an official deadline, but we could say the end of October. Always best to apply early.

Cool opportunity! I assume that EA knowledge is not a requirement at all?

9
Jamie B
EA knowledge is not required. Thanks for asking!

Your group can hold a watch party of the movie about Petrov: The Man Who Saved the World. Then maybe discuss it a bit after!

The title should be Rotterdam instead of Rottedam :)

Edited to add: Thanks for fixing!

I'm happy this exists and I like the logo!

5
Michael Townsend🔸
Credit goes to Alex Savard :)

Thanks for doing this! I think it's worth specifying though in the post and in the website that the website does not include full-time positions. 

Saying "we include a wide range of non-full-time positions" doesn't convey that you don't include full-time positions, and people might wonder why full-time positions aren't here. I think it was clearer that it didn't include full-time positions when it was called the EA Internships Board.

3
michel
Agree, I should make this more explicit. Made edits to reflect this change in this post and on the website.

It's great that CFAR is running workshops again. I've heard great things about them and would like to join one in the future (though I probably will not join these ones in Prague).

I just want to ask why the info above isn't reflected on the CFAR website yet? When will it be reflected there if ever? I think it would help increase the legitimacy and appeal of these workshops, rather than having people go to a Forum post with no photos.

3
IrenaK
Hi Brian,  I hope that you'll eventually be able to make it to the workshops, we certainly hope that there will be more next year. Eventually, we would like to update the website but we have limited capacity and we were focused on getting the dates and applications out there as early as we knew they were happening so people could pencil in the dates. Now we are also running admissions, coordinating staff, working on content and logistics etc. Given all of this,  it will likely take us a couple of more weeks to update.

I agree that student groups should prioritize succession planning, so thanks for writing this! Just want to note for readers of this post that the EA Groups Resource Centre has this resource on Handing Over Leadership. It could use some updating (such as linking to this post), which we'll probably do over the next few weeks, but I think it has helpful information and resources on how to go about succession planning.

Thanks for sharing the database links Luke! I wasn't aware FTX had that, but it definitely makes sense that they do.

Interesting, I wasn't familiar with this connotation (even if I watch quite a few sports). 

To me the name Asterisk is decent, but yeah it might not be a good one if it would be confused with other search results or journals/magazines, like asteriskjournal.org as noted by Azure here

1[comment deleted]

Cool project! Could I ask why it's called Asterisk?

I liked that it brings up associations with risk, stars/space/a bigger, stranger future, and a healthy dose of pedantry. Part of the "EA mindset" I'm trying to illustrate is the urge to investigate claims in more depth. We like footnotes – hence, Asterisk. 

0
Josh Jacobson
The name seems potentially quite bad. To me, the connotation is that everything in it should be taken with an asterisk. E.g. its meaning as described here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asterisk#Competitive_sports_and_games

Thanks for this post! Just pointing out that the links in footnotes 3 and 4 seem to all be not working

Edit: They were working, just had to do a captcha

[This comment is no longer endorsed by its author]Reply
3
Guy Raveh
They currently work for me.

These resources on promoting your group and events from the EA Groups Resource Centre might help! https://resources.eagroups.org/running-a-group/promotion-advertising

I suggest you change the title to say 80K advising rather than consulting, since that's what they refer to it as. I was wondering if 80K launched a new consulting service!

8
devansh
Ah, good point. Done!

Cool program! One question on this:

We've already invited a first cohort of 21 regrantors to test the program.

Will you be announcing who these regrantors are, and when will that happen if so?

3
leopold
Thanks! We are not planning to publish the list of regrantors for now.

Thanks for the info! Yeah intensities of workouts matter too. 

Interesting! How often and for how many hours per week do you work out now in VR (and how many hrs not in VR per week now)? And how often and for how many hours did you work out per week before?

9
Yonatan Cale
Trying to answer your question: I estimate I do 30-60 minutes per day in VR, plus about 5 minutes without VR (doing TRX or pullups once in a while) Before VR: There is a ton of variance. At good weeks I'd do 2-3 rollerblade trips per week (each is several hours) plus ~10 minutes per day of something like pullups (which is also something I can say more about) [I haven't been in a "good week" for at least 3 months] ---------------------------------------- This questions seems a bit "wrong"  because: 1. The intensity of the workout can be extremely high 1. 2-3 minutes in this specific VR game were enough to get my brother extremely exhausted for about half a day 2. My activity tracker (Oura ring [note it is optimized for sleep tracking, not workout tracking]) rates many VR sessions as "exceeds the hight of our chart", it is literally off the charts . Note this is higher than the hardest parts of rollerblade trips that I do with groups that are better than me and really like going up hills, followed by going up even more hills 3. My subjective experience matches this. I recognize when my body goes into extremely high pulse levels, and I can say more about sore muscles and so on 1. I am already able to do 3-5 rounds of this crazy game (3 minutes each), which would be unimaginable a few weeks ago 2. This means (A) I'm getting more fit, but also (B) the workouts are really short. I can currently tire myself out completely in about 15 minutes, which makes asking about "how much time I spend working out" like the wrong metric, I think 4. [Note you don't have to play this crazy game, or you can play it more calmly, if all of this sounds too extreme. But to me it is exciting] 2. The only reason I'm not working out right now is in order to be productive. I literally need willpower in order to not-work-out, this is crazy. I'm saying this in case you're trying to figure out if I'm ABLE to get enough sports out of VR

I like the Sankey diagram too - what did you use to make it Yi-Yang?

7
Yi-Yang
This! https://flourish.studio/visualisations/sankey-charts/

The title should say February 2022 instead of 2021! :)

4
AppliedDivinityStudies
Oh man, fixed, thank you.

Really happy to see this book being available widely now and publicized more! I'll copy over my Goodreads review here below. I highly recommend the book:

"This was the most useful book I read in 2021. It's an amazing book for people interested in making a large impact with their career, especially those interested in starting a charity or working for one. They tell you why and how to start a high-impact charity, while giving you the tools and tips to make great decisions as a charity entrepreneur, which are useful even if you don't start a charity. Give it ... (read more)

I think this is a good idea and is probably worth it for one or more people to try making this happen!

Thanks for this post! I agree this is a problem, and the solution of talking about yours or others' career changes or motivated reasoning seems promising.

I like this post and find it valuable - thanks Akash!

Load more