Effective Altruism Forum
EA Forum

Hide table of contents
Comment Permalink
Matt_Sharp3
3
0

This sounds potentially valuable. However, it's important to establish what the added value of this project would be. 

What current processes/systems/databases do scientists currently use to identify relevant research and bacteria? What about these existing processes/systems/databases is most in need of improving? Which scientists in the field have you spoken to about this in order to identify the main challenges they face when using existing systems?

Also...is there a reason for only focusing on antibiotic producing bacteria and not including fungi?

Reply
1[anonymous]
1. I agree, 2. None, I didn't even think to ask scientists what the process is like for them. That's on me. 3. I forgot to use a more general term that also includes non-bacterial antibiotic producers, my bad
1
CAISID
People are hitting you with the negative karma BUT I think this is actually quite a valuable experience. Lots of research is trying, seeing what works or doesn't, adapting, then trying again. No shame in it at all. If you address Number 2, let us know how you get on :)
[anonymous]0
0
0

I will if/when I do address it

Reply
See in context
by [anonymous]
1 min read 8

-4

BiosecurityOpportunities to take action
Frontpage

I am looking for people to help/give feedback on a biosecurity project.

Salary: none

Location: Remote (Global)

Application: email me at wesreisen2@gmail.com saying you'd like to help, preferably with some details on what you'd expect to do, as well as what you're good at. There is no deadline/rolling basis.

Suggested skills and/or requirements: 

There are no requirements, but there are some 'Nice-to-haves':

  1. Enjoying working with a team,
  2. Code (namely, the ability to automate collecting information from the web).

Other notes about the project:

The goal of the project (which is not set in stone) is to make it easier for people to find bacteria that create antibiotics, [1] and make it easier to discover new antibiotics.  The end result is something along the lines of:

A dataset of antibiotic-producing bacteria (or promising research on the topic, or potential APBs), including links about each bacteria, such that labs can easily find new antibiotics and/or easily develop systems to make antibiotics, and more.

In the project, the main next step is to develop a system that scans the web for antibiotic-producing bacteria (APB), [2] and collects information (such as the source of the information) on said bacteria. (the 'scanner' doesn't need to be right 100% of the time, just right enough to make the search for APB much easier.)  It has come to my attention that antibiotics take too much time to go from discovery to clinical use, so the plan is under revision.

The project plan (which is not set in stone) is available here.

(Note: this is unofficial, and not what one would consider a 'job'.)

 

Update: it turns out, someone already did this! (Data Management and Communications – Gryphon Scientific)

  1. ^

    Bacteria sometimes develop antibiotics as a defense mechanism.

  2. ^

    This is the official term for it, according to GPT-4, and based on the papers I've read so far, this is the term that is used.

-4

0
3

Reactions

0
3
Comments8
Sorted by
New & upvoted
Click to highlight new comments since:
Matt_Sharp3
3
0

This sounds potentially valuable. However, it's important to establish what the added value of this project would be. 

What current processes/systems/databases do scientists currently use to identify relevant research and bacteria? What about these existing processes/systems/databases is most in need of improving? Which scientists in the field have you spoken to about this in order to identify the main challenges they face when using existing systems?

Also...is there a reason for only focusing on antibiotic producing bacteria and not including fungi?

Reply
[anonymous]1
1
0
  1. I agree,
  2. None, I didn't even think to ask scientists what the process is like for them. That's on me.
  3. I forgot to use a more general term that also includes non-bacterial antibiotic producers, my bad
Reply
CAISID1
0
0

People are hitting you with the negative karma BUT I think this is actually quite a valuable experience. Lots of research is trying, seeing what works or doesn't, adapting, then trying again. No shame in it at all. If you address Number 2, let us know how you get on :)

Reply
[anonymous]0
0
0

I will if/when I do address it

Reply
CAISID1
0
0

This sounds interesting, Wes. Can you give any insight into the end-goal of the project? What would be the purpose of the database of APB from the internet? Does this tie in to a larger project?

Reply
[anonymous]-2
0
0

I'll respond in ∼30 mins

Reply
[anonymous]1
0
0
  1. Since antibiotic resistance (the issue of disease-causing bacteria evolving resistance to antibiotics, one of the main defenses against disease-causing bacteria) is a big issue, work in that area (namely, making the process of finding new antibiotics that disease-causing bacteria is not resistant to) is therefore helpful.
  2. The database would make it easier to identify APBs.
  3. In a sense, this ties into the larger project because it largely is the larger project.
Reply
CAISID1
0
0

Ah, okay. And scientists have no more of an efficient way to do this, currently? My field is law, but we have updates from government and from special interest bodies to keep us informed on new legislation and policy - do biology scientists not have something similar? Not dunking on or giving negative feedback on your idea, just trying to figure out what the USP is.

It may be worth reaching out to some researchers in this field and asking for feedback on the idea, and then adapting it to suit. Do you have a list of contacts, or know where to begin? 

I have zero biosecurity experience but lots of general research experience. I'm happy to field questions via IM if you think that would be useful for you. 

Reply
Curated and popular this week
Relevant opportunities
View more