Hi everyone! I'm new here, so perhaps I have missed a resource on the forum that can help me with this and I hope it is OK to post this question. Since a few months I have been helping to run a mutual aid page on Instagram that takes requests from all over the world. A few things have struck me in the past months while working on this:
- The majority of requests are coming from Black people in the US.
- We have very few white American followers.
- Most of our followers are young (18-24), Black/Brown/Indigenous/Asian, queer, neurodivergent, or otherwise marginalised.
Basically, it looks to me like funds are being passed around within a group of people that already has little wealth to go around, and I think we need to get more wealthy white Americans to donate. I frequently donate to homeless people in the US that we get requests from myself, but as a Dutch person it does feel odd to have to be sending funds to literally the richest country on earth because Americans don't take care of their own. I was wondering whether people on this forum have any experience getting white, wealthy, older generations on board? Thanks!
Isn't the whole point of mutual aid societies that they are made up of relatively similar people all helping each other out? This means that all can benefit, and they can use their knowledge of each other's circumstances to provide more appropriate assistance. What you're looking for sounds much more like traditional charity, which is indeed dominated by wealthy people. I recommend checking out GiveDirectly. They target the poorest people, and are probably also better equipped to prevent the misuse of funds.
I'm not sure it's key to mutual aid that people are similar demographically, I'd say the key point of it is to share resources unconditionally. A traditional charity does not give unconditionally, as they gate-keep who is or isn't 'deserving' enough of help (that's not to say that traditional charities can't do great work of course). Mutual aid also recognises that different people's needs might be different: one person might need financial assistance to avoid eviction, another might need a second-hand mobility aid, and another might need a hot meal brought over a few times a week. So the aid is mutual, because the same people might be recipients of some types of aid and givers of others, if that makes sense.
GiveDirectly makes unconditional cash transfers so that sounds like what you are looking for?