Comments
Donating to a charity in someone else's name feels like a worse gift to me, and maybe unhealthy in EA circles. Would be interested in seeing people's anecdata to the contrary however! :)
Donating to a charity in someone else's name feels like a worse gift to me, and maybe unhealthy in EA circles. Would be interested in seeing people's anecdata to the contrary however! :)
As far as I know, the "tradition of just making a fixed donation to a specific charity in someone else's name" isn't a thing in the EA community. Rather it is something that I've heard of ordinary folks doing during the holidays as an alternative to a physical gift. Along the lines of "You like animals, so I donated to the local animal shelter on your behalf -- here is a little brochure/receipt about it." It strikes me as weird too, which is why I like the idea of giving people lots of choice so they have more say in "their" donation.
I also agree that it would be weird for already-committed EAs to get into the habit of gifting eachother a bunch of regranting funds. (There's enough of that craziness going on already!) But like I said, I think EA gift cards could make for a great way to introduce new people to the movement.
feels like a worse gift to me
maybe unhealthy in EA circles
Could you explain a little bit about the above?
My first impression seems in favor of the OP. I haven't thought about your considerations, which seem important.
I like this idea a lot. I spent O($1k) on giftcards this year from tisbest instead of giving more traditional gifts. This is nice in multiple ways: this is way more than I would have spent on regular gifts, and each person gets the chance to give to something they care about. And selfishly I get a tax deduction (although I would have gotten it anyway since most of this money would have been donated anyway) and get to push my agenda on family that giving money is good (this doesn't seem like the worst thing in the world, but I'll take it for what it is: I'm doing something that I hope will cause them to be more inclined to make marginally more altruistic choices).
There's not an easy way for me to make this about EA, though, other than if they ask for advice or something like that, since it ruins the gift a bit if I push them in some direction. But if the gift card mechanism could somehow nudge them towards effective charities, that would be awesome.
I'd love to be able to give my family & friends gift cards that let them choose which EA charity they'll donate to. These would be more restrictive than overall charity gift cards where the funds can go to any tax-deductible organization. (Of the sort provided by every.org or tisbest.) But they would be more flexible than the tradition of just making a fixed donation to a specific charity in someone else's name. I want to load up a card with anywhere from $50 to $5000, then give it to my friend for them to allocate the cash among a curated selection of EA charities.
EA gift cards could be a really fun way to introduce people to effective altruism and make a positive impression. I'm thinking you'd redeem the gift cards on a website that contains materials explaining the overall concept of EA, followed by brief introductions to some individual wings of the movement: global development, x-risk reduction, animal welfare, cause prioritization, etc, explaining why each is a contender for the coveted title of most-effective.
Maybe clicking into each wing takes you to a page that explains the rationale for that wing in more detail, followed by a breakdown into sub-areas. X-risk would become AI vs biorisk vs others. Global development might become Against Malaria Foundation, versus more hits-based health interventions like deworming, versus economic growth interventions. And so forth. Just like on effectivecrypto.org, you could donate to either a cause-area bundle or your own custom mix of individual charities. Finally, of course, after the donation we could ask if people want to be signed up for the EA Newsletter or engage in other ways.
Pros:
Cons:
SoGive piloted charity gift cards some years ago.
Our charity donations product worked as follows:
The successful bits:
The less successful bits
We then experimented with the model. We tried a different product where the gift recipient receives 50% charity donation, 50% Amazon gift voucher. This was more successful, in that the amount of charity donations generated at least exceeded the advertising costs. However this was not sufficient -- we had set a more demanding goal than this, and it did not reach that target.
We did not target the EA community, as we were aiming for impact, and didn't want to target users whose counterfactuals involved donating to high impact charities anyway.
"We did not target the EA community [...]"
Did you consider that EAs might want to provide this as a gift to their non-EA friends or family? Personally, it seems like one of the most likely ways/instances in which I would introduce some of my connections to EA charities.