Effective Altruism Forum
EA Forum

Hide table of contents
by Michal Greidinger
5 min read 4

40

Building effective altruismCommunityDiversity and inclusionPractical
Frontpage

EA communities tend to be a professional space and a social space, all at once. This reality can often involve complex power dynamics that require careful attention. To maintain safe spaces, it is crucial to establish guiding rules for our communities. In this post, I would like to share EA Israel's concise code of conduct for preventing sexual harassment, which is based on Israeli law. Before diving into that, we suggest some practical steps you can take to promote the safety of your community.[1]

What can you do to prevent sexual harassment in your EA community?

As a community manager

Designate a responsible person, either a team member or volunteer, dedicated to sexual harassment prevention and community health in your community. This person should be committed to this subject, ideally with some professional experience in dealing with emotionally challenging situation. Nominate another person, preferably from a different gender, as a contact person when the main representative is unavailable / connected to the harassment case / just in case someone prefers to speak with someone else.

Ensure they receive professional training, including emotional and legal aspects, that they are able to commit to this role for a long-enough duration, and that they establish a code of conduct against sexual harassment.

As a community health and preventing sexual harassment representative

Set a code of conduct to prevent sexual harassment and publish it widely, so that every old and new community member encounters it at some point. Clearly identify yourself as the primary point of contact for addressing harassment issues, and make it super-easy to contact you.

As a community member

Ask your community manager to nominate a responsible person for sexual harassment prevention and community health. Ask for the adoption of a code of conduct, such as the one shared in this post, or encourage the development of a customized code of conduct that suits your community's needs and fits the local law.

You, as an EA worker or a community member, can help to create an environment where everyone feels respected and protected. 

EA Israel’s Code of Conduct for preventing sexual harassment

The rest of this section is EA Israel’s short version code of conduct, based on the Israeli law.

Effective Altruism Israel strives to create a sense of safety and comfort among its staff and community. Sexual harassment is strictly against the organization's policy.

Prohibited acts according to the law

  1. Threatening or coercing a person to engage in acts of a sexual nature.
  2. Indecent acts / lascivious behaviour.
  3. Repeated proposals of a sexually oriented nature, even if the person to whom the proposals are directed has shown a lack of interest in them. However, there is no need to demonstrate a "lack of interest" in a relationship of authority with an inherent power imbalance, or in a dependent, educational or therapeutic relationship with a minor, a patient, or someone defenseless in other ways.
  4. Persistent references focused on a person's sex or sexuality, even if the person to whom the behavior is directed has shown disinterest. There is no need to demonstrate "lack of interest" in cases mentioned in paragraph (3) above.
  5. Derogatory or demeaning treatment towards a person regarding their sex or sexuality, including their sexual orientation, whether or not they have expressed that it bothers them.
  6. Publishing a photograph, film, or recording that focuses on a person's sexuality, in circumstances where the publication may degrade or demean the person, and consent for publication has not been given.
  7. Prohibited retaliation: Harming a person as a result of sexual harassment towards them or any harm to someone who has assisted or testified on behalf of another person in a complaint about sexual harassment.

Process for Filing a Complaint

The law provides three options, any or all of which can be pursued simultaneously or one after the other:

  1. Internal disciplinary procedure - One can file a complaint regarding the harassment with the person in charge of handling cases of sexual harassment at the organization according to the Sexual Harassment Prevention Law. The designated responsible person at "Effective Altruism Israel" is Michal Greidinger, [contact details].  Filing a complaint with the responsible person initiates internal disciplinary proceedings. If the designated responsible person is connected to the case in any way, one can file a complaint with Ezra Hausdorff, the organization's CEO.
  2. Criminal procedure - One can file a complaint with the police to initiate criminal proceedings.
  3. Civil procedure - Within seven years, one can file a civil lawsuit in court (usually the Regional Labor Court). The court may rule in cases of sexual harassment or retaliation an award compensation of up to 120,000 NIS without proof of damages.

Handling the Complaint (Internal disciplinary procedure)

  • The responsible person will proceed to clarify the complaint, listen to those involved and to witnesses, and verify the information.
  • The complainant will be informed about the procedures for handling sexual harassment or retaliation according to the law.
  • The responsible person will not handle the complaint if they have a personal connection to the subject of the complaint or those involved, and will transfer the investigation to another responsible person, such as a designated representative, a community manager, or the CEO.
  • The investigation of the complaint will be conducted efficiently and without delay.
  • The investigation of the complaint will be carried out with utmost respect for the dignity and privacy of the complainant, the accused, and witnesses, while safeguarding the rights of those involved, and the confidentiality of the information.
  • Upon completion of the investigation, the designated responsible person will promptly submit a written summary of the investigation to the CEO, along with detailed recommendations for further action to prevent ongoing sexual harassment, and to address any harm caused to the complainant.
  • Within seven days, the CEO will decide on further action with the aim of preventing ongoing sexual harassment and addressing any harm caused to the complainant.
  • The CEO will protect the complainant during the investigation from any negative impact on their organizational involvement resulting from the complaint and, among other measures deemed appropriate, will take steps to distance the accused from the complainant to the extent appropriate and possible.
  • The CEO will provide the complainant with a detailed written notification of their decision and allow the complainant to view the responsible person's summary and recommendations.

Actions taken by "Effective Altruism Israel" to prevent sexual harassment

  • Appointment of a designated individual for the prevention of sexual harassment (Michal Greidinger, [contact details]).
  • The "Effective Altruism Israel" team is committed to participating in training and awareness programs coordinated by the organization regarding the prevention of sexual harassment and retaliation.
  • The organization requires all employees, board members, volunteers and community members to refrain from engaging in sexual harassment and retaliation, both among employees and within the community.
  • The organization publishes and makes accessible the code of conduct for the prevention of sexual harassment to the organization's team and the community.

In addition to the above, with mutual consent and agreement, an intimate relationship may exist between different individuals involved in the organization. In the event of the formation of an intimate relationship with mutual consent between an employee/manager and another employee, manager or community member, it is the responsibility of the employee/manager to inform the designated responsible person at the organization of their relationship, as soon as possible, in order to prevention the exploitation of power dynamics and to ensure professional conduct at the workplace.

 

For the full code of conduct

 

For further information, you can contact me at michal@effective-altruism.org.il

For translation and feedback on this post, thanks to Sarah Winthrope, Edo Arad, Avital Shkolnik and Ezra Hausdorff. 

 

  1. ^

     I am pleased to see that other community organizers are also focusing on community health. Here is the recent EA Germany post regarding the subject. 

40

0
0

Reactions

0
0

More posts like this

Comments4


Sorted by
New & upvoted
Click to highlight new comments since:
Julia_Wise🔸10
1
0

Thank you for sharing this! Here's a guide that includes links to some other codes of conduct from EA groups.

Reply
Yonatan Cale7
2
0

Hey,

It sounds to me like you're mainly focusing on

  1. Nominating a representative (who gets training)
  2. Filing a complaint

 

This seems to me (not that I'm an expert, at all) like there's still something missing: having the representative be actually trustworthy. I have no idea how training could accomplish that.

I know you personally and my sense is that you deeply care about this, your heart is in it, you deeply care about listening and understanding people's needs, and even if you won't know how to do something - I could communicate my needs to you and nothing bad would happen because of it, you'd listen and we'd figure something out.

This is not at all the vibe I got from "representatives" throughout my career. It often seems like an "annoying extra task" that someone got and must do, like "decide who does a shift (שמירה) at what times". I really doubt a simple training could solve this (not a training that I'd know how to run, anyway) (not a training that those representatives got).

Also, (again, not an expert) - I don't think that a common thing people would want is to "file a complaint" or to have an "internal disciplinary procedure". I imagine that more common desires would be "keep it secret please" or "get that person far away from me without them knowing its my fault" or maybe something simpler like "believe me".

Also (again, not an expert) - I don't think that relying on "prohibited acts according to the law" would make many people calm. I sometimes hear about things that are (I hope?) clearly illegal, done publicly, recorded, and the law doesn't seem to help enough. Also - filing a complaint in the police is maybe something worth getting training about, but I hear that filing such complaints come with huge downsides (which annoys me and I won't rant about it, but I would hope the representative won't rely on that solution).

 

My guess is that much of this comes naturally to you, but if I imagine myself running an EA group or so, and reading this post, these are some things that would be missing for me, things where I'd still feel somewhat lost even with your advice. Maybe you want to write more? Run your own courses? I really have no idea

 

Congrats on your first post!

:)

Reply
SummaryBot3
0
0

Executive summary: The post offers practical steps for EA communities to prevent sexual harassment, including designating responsible personnel, establishing a code of conduct, and training. It shares EA Israel's concise code of conduct based on Israeli law.

Key points:

  1. Community managers should designate responsible personnel for harassment prevention who receive training.
  2. Establish and publish a clear code of conduct based on local laws.
  3. The shared code prohibits coercive acts, indecent behavior, unwanted advances, derogatory treatment, unauthorized publication of private material, and retaliation.
  4. It outlines complaint procedures: internal, criminal, civil.
  5. Internally, it requires prompt, respectful investigations and recommendations to leadership.
  6. Leaders must take action to address harm and prevent further harassment.
  7. Additional steps include training, requiring staff/volunteers to refrain from harassment, and publishing the code.

 

This comment was auto-generated by the EA Forum Team. Feel free to point out issues with this summary by replying to the comment, and contact us if you have feedback.

Reply
Milena Canzler🔸1
0
0

Hey Michal, thanks for sharing this code and also some thoughts on how to take preventative measures depending on your position in the community. I especially like that you included community members, and encouraged people to advocate for what they want!

Reply
Curated and popular this week
Paul Present
 ·  · 28m read
 · 
Note: I am not a malaria expert. This is my best-faith attempt at answering a question that was bothering me, but this field is a large and complex field, and I’ve almost certainly misunderstood something somewhere along the way. Summary While the world made incredible progress in reducing malaria cases from 2000 to 2015, the past 10 years have seen malaria cases stop declining and start rising. I investigated potential reasons behind this increase through reading the existing literature and looking at publicly available data, and I identified three key factors explaining the rise: 1. Population Growth: Africa's population has increased by approximately 75% since 2000. This alone explains most of the increase in absolute case numbers, while cases per capita have remained relatively flat since 2015. 2. Stagnant Funding: After rapid growth starting in 2000, funding for malaria prevention plateaued around 2010. 3. Insecticide Resistance: Mosquitoes have become increasingly resistant to the insecticides used in bednets over the past 20 years. This has made older models of bednets less effective, although they still have some effect. Newer models of bednets developed in response to insecticide resistance are more effective but still not widely deployed.  I very crudely estimate that without any of these factors, there would be 55% fewer malaria cases in the world than what we see today. I think all three of these factors are roughly equally important in explaining the difference.  Alternative explanations like removal of PFAS, climate change, or invasive mosquito species don't appear to be major contributors.  Overall this investigation made me more convinced that bednets are an effective global health intervention.  Introduction In 2015, malaria rates were down, and EAs were celebrating. Giving What We Can posted this incredible gif showing the decrease in malaria cases across Africa since 2000: Giving What We Can said that > The reduction in malaria has be
Rory Fenton
 ·  · 6m read
 · 
Cross-posted from my blog. Contrary to my carefully crafted brand as a weak nerd, I go to a local CrossFit gym a few times a week. Every year, the gym raises funds for a scholarship for teens from lower-income families to attend their summer camp program. I don’t know how many Crossfit-interested low-income teens there are in my small town, but I’ll guess there are perhaps 2 of them who would benefit from the scholarship. After all, CrossFit is pretty niche, and the town is small. Helping youngsters get swole in the Pacific Northwest is not exactly as cost-effective as preventing malaria in Malawi. But I notice I feel drawn to supporting the scholarship anyway. Every time it pops in my head I think, “My money could fully solve this problem”. The camp only costs a few hundred dollars per kid and if there are just 2 kids who need support, I could give $500 and there would no longer be teenagers in my town who want to go to a CrossFit summer camp but can’t. Thanks to me, the hero, this problem would be entirely solved. 100%. That is not how most nonprofit work feels to me. You are only ever making small dents in important problems I want to work on big problems. Global poverty. Malaria. Everyone not suddenly dying. But if I’m honest, what I really want is to solve those problems. Me, personally, solve them. This is a continued source of frustration and sadness because I absolutely cannot solve those problems. Consider what else my $500 CrossFit scholarship might do: * I want to save lives, and USAID suddenly stops giving $7 billion a year to PEPFAR. So I give $500 to the Rapid Response Fund. My donation solves 0.000001% of the problem and I feel like I have failed. * I want to solve climate change, and getting to net zero will require stopping or removing emissions of 1,500 billion tons of carbon dioxide. I give $500 to a policy nonprofit that reduces emissions, in expectation, by 50 tons. My donation solves 0.000000003% of the problem and I feel like I have f
LewisBollard
 ·  · 8m read
 · 
> How the dismal science can help us end the dismal treatment of farm animals By Martin Gould ---------------------------------------- Note: This post was crossposted from the Open Philanthropy Farm Animal Welfare Research Newsletter by the Forum team, with the author's permission. The author may not see or respond to comments on this post. ---------------------------------------- This year we’ll be sharing a few notes from my colleagues on their areas of expertise. The first is from Martin. I’ll be back next month. - Lewis In 2024, Denmark announced plans to introduce the world’s first carbon tax on cow, sheep, and pig farming. Climate advocates celebrated, but animal advocates should be much more cautious. When Denmark’s Aarhus municipality tested a similar tax in 2022, beef purchases dropped by 40% while demand for chicken and pork increased. Beef is the most emissions-intensive meat, so carbon taxes hit it hardest — and Denmark’s policies don’t even cover chicken or fish. When the price of beef rises, consumers mostly shift to other meats like chicken. And replacing beef with chicken means more animals suffer in worse conditions — about 190 chickens are needed to match the meat from one cow, and chickens are raised in much worse conditions. It may be possible to design carbon taxes which avoid this outcome; a recent paper argues that a broad carbon tax would reduce all meat production (although it omits impacts on egg or dairy production). But with cows ten times more emissions-intensive than chicken per kilogram of meat, other governments may follow Denmark’s lead — focusing taxes on the highest emitters while ignoring the welfare implications. Beef is easily the most emissions-intensive meat, but also requires the fewest animals for a given amount. The graph shows climate emissions per tonne of meat on the right-hand side, and the number of animals needed to produce a kilogram of meat on the left. The fish “lives lost” number varies significantly by
Recent opportunities in Building effective altruism
7
EAGxNordics in Norway: apply now
Amalie Farestvedt 🔸
· · 3m read
0
0
32
Introducing Effective Accountability: Project and Job Search Accountability Groups
2 authors
· · 2m read
1
1
15
Applications to EAGxCDMX close in a week!
cescorza
· · 2m read
0
0
View more