I’ve spent the last 2 years organizing my EA university group, and the last year or so thinking about and running retreats for university students. Just this last weekend, I helped organize the sixth Midwest EA retreat. One thing I realized while running the retreat was that I didn’t automatically have a good sense of how the retreat was going for the median participant. If there was a moment where I was personally pleased or displeased, this didn’t necessarily have any connection to how the other attendees described their feelings when asked. The set of experiences I was having at the retreat was very different from theirs.
It used to be that I could figure out how to make a retreat better by just asking “is this working for me personally?” I could experience the retreat as a half-organizer, half-attendee, and use my experience as an attendee to guide my organizing. Now I’m all-organizer, and this doesn’t really work. I feel like I’ve lost something.
When I do 1-1s at a retreat, I’m often talking to students much newer to EA than me. For lack of a better word, I think they’re often scared of EA. Even if the individual EAs they meet are rather nice, they recognize, perhaps correctly, that EA as a whole is this expansive and demanding thing. Not unreasonably, they are unsure what to do about this demandingness. They have many things they care about beyond EA, and it can feel to them that EA is fighting for every square inch of their care and attention[1][2].
Or at least that’s my guess, because I don’t feel the same. When I talk to these students, I feel no hesitation about whether you should orient your life around EA or something else, and I have to remind myself that this hesitation is natural and normal. If I think even more, I can remember that I once felt the same way these students did, and how (for lack of a better word) scared I was then.
I think it’s pretty obvious that my psychological distance from the students I’m talking to makes me a worse advocate of EA ideas. Without even thinking about it, I might come off as much more callous and inconsiderate than I would want to be, or otherwise fail to meet this person where they are. A part of me wishes I was still a little scared, or at least could remember this feeling and its intensity.
In both of these cases, my success as an organizer and my increasing commitment to EA[3] has had some downsides for my work as a community builder. Moving up the value chain, from club member, to junior organizer, to established organizer, to senior organizer and mentor to others, has been good in many ways. I am happier, more successful, and probably much more impactful[4]. But I’m also just further from the experience of those I’m trying to help and support. This has been a worthwhile tradeoff to make so far. While I feel some sort of loss, I don’t have regrets. But if all goes well, I’ve only just started moving up the value chain, and I’m worried about what comes next[5].
I think being a good community builder is a bit about having the right theory of change/strategy, and a lot about micro-level execution. Once you have a decent high-level strategy[6], and you’ve decided on some activities or programming that you want to do, you have a seemingly infinite number of little tasks to do. Send out this email, create this meeting agenda, decide on a presenter, facilitate this week of the fellowship, prep for your 1-1, have your 1-1, reflect on any or all of the above, repeat.
And because in each of these cases you’re dealing with messy, nonlinear people, there’s a large difference between good and great performance. To put it differently, the outcomes for each of these activities are very convex with respect to the quality of your work. Most 1-1’s are mediocre, but some change lives. Most bits of organizer feedback you give will be banal, but some will change how the group operates. Most of the links you send will go unread, but some may be incredibly meaningful. There’s of course something to be said for accumulation, for doing lots of slightly good things that add up over time[7]. But I think it can often be quite tricky to do things as an organizer that are slightly good instead of completely forgettable. I generally believe a great organizer can easily be an order of magnitude more impactful than a good one, and a great organizer is great because they do dozens of small things well.
And the reason these great organizers do the small things well is because they are competent, and they have good models of both the students they work with and the tasks they’re doing. I don’t expect to get any less competent in the future, but I’m concerned for my models. As I move from being an organizer who runs one group and two retreats to being a professional that tries to help many groups and many retreats, my models of the typical university EA or university EA organizer experience will get worse, and at some point, this might prevent me from really helping with all those small things that are the difference between a good and a great community builder. Instead of giving advice that connects directly to an organizer or student’s immediate experience, I could end up spewing helpful-sounding vague platitudes.
That moving up the value chain could be bad for you is not a new idea. As a kid, I received my first introduction to the notion when reading my dad’s book collections of Dilbert[8]. But in much of the world, middle managers are fine, and moving up the value chain doesn’t really prevent you from having an impact. In university community building, however, the groups in your care are spread across the nation or the world, and so I think it’s quite reasonable to worry that your models of what’s happening on the ground might turn to mush.
I have some ideas for how to prevent this and hold onto decent models while helping many different university groups. I figure the first step in keeping good models is to ingest lots of information. I want to be physically present at lots of university group activities and spend a lot of time hearing from organizers and group members about how things are going. For this to work well, I will need to maintain my willingness to travel and/or live near a university group. I also will need to get somewhat better at having conversations that generate a high volume of useful information[9].
Once I have all of this information, I don’t think it’s guaranteed that I’ll be in a psychological position to accept the information and work it into my model. In the worst case, I might instead just focus on my memory of how things used to work for me or fit every piece of data into some overly simplistic abstract model I’ve come up with[10]. In the best case, I’m not sure exactly what I’ll do, but it will probably involve plenty of psychological openness and humility. One way for me to create more psychological openness might be to spend less time actively working and so leave myself more time to process the information I’ve received into something useful.
Additionally, something that might help with both my first and second steps here is dogfooding and just doing some of the work or running a group myself from time to time. This might look like helping to run the occasional general meeting, tabling for a group at the start of the semester, or just talking to students new to EA from time to time. In each of these cases, I’ll get a little information, but more importantly, I’ll get a sense of how it feels to organize something, which will probably help my openness quite a bit.
In an ideal world, I’ll do all these things and more, and so I’ll hold onto my models of organizing and being an EA student, even as everything else about my life shifts. When I talk to organizers and students, I’ll do so from a position of authority and seniority, but I’ll still be able to understand what it’s like to be them, and the particular sorts of challenges they’re facing. This understanding will allow me to be more impactful, of course, but I want more than just impact here. It gives me a lot of pleasure right now to be the sort of person that actually understands, who doesn’t just bat around abstractions, and I hope to be that person for the university organizers in my care long into the future.
There are of course students who in my view are not (for lack of a better word) scared enough.
Students who end up in this position are probably unusually open to the idea that EA is winning in this fight, but that doesn’t make up for the fact that it’s a fight.
A year ago, I did not expect to pursue an impactful career, but now I’m almost certain I will.
The impact of a community builder on long run impact is extremely hard to measure, so it’s appropriate for me to be uncertain about this.
I presently think it’s pretty likely I will work professionally supporting university EA groups after I graduate this winter. Given the content of this post, it would be kind of funny if this didn’t happen, and extremely funny if this post was the cause.
This is a decent example.
Most people’s positions don’t change in the space of a single conversation, and I would be worried if they did.
One obvious way for me to improve here is to shut up more often.
This has of course never happened to me before.