Nov 4, 2021 (post-EA Global) update: my revised, slightly better written and less melodramatic version has been up here, so making this a linkpost! In the name of transparency, not editing anything below. But I recommend you read the linked version instead!
Note: I wrote this for personal blog, but thought I would put it here first, perhaps to incorporate any feedback I get. It may be "preaching to the choir" a bit.
Content warning: descriptions of very bad experiences. Not particularly graphic but may be disturbing. This is not going to be a fun article to read, but I hope you will read it anyway.
I am writing these words while sitting in an comfortable chair in a comfortable 70 degree house. And, I suspect, you are too. Basically comfortable, that is. Physically. Maybe you’re a little cold, but not consumed by the screaming anguish of an icy ocean you cannot escape. Maybe stressed, but not asphyxiating.
It’s times like these I find it far too easy to ignore the most urgent, most serious, most fundamental problem in our world.
Once in a while, most of us endure suffering that completely consumes us. This need not be as severe as the horrors your mind can conjure. A kidney stone. Childbirth. Stubbing your toe, hard, even. During those first first few seconds as your nerves radiate electrical signals up your leg, through your spine and into your brain, there is nothing else in the world but pain.
Talking—indeed, even thinking—about intense, acute suffering is not cool, fun, or sexy. We flinch away from it, in both memory and observational understanding. We understand tragedies by the number they kill, sidestepping the very process of death. We understand torture as a ‘human right abuse’ without staring directly in its face.
I was just watching “The Edge of Democracy” on Netflix. The narrator mentions that Dilma Rousseff, former president of Brazil, was tortured in 1970 by the Brazilian military. The documentary does not linger on this fact.
Sitting in a comfortable chair in a comfortable house, it is easy to mentally replace “tortured” with a more manageable word. “Imprisoned,” maybe, or even “beaten up.” Unjust imprisonment is an evil, but it is an evil I believe we understand. I can imagine myself in prison and I can imagine the accompanying mental anguish, but I cannot imagine myself being tortured. Not really.
Language is perhaps humanity’s most powerful tool, but its power is limited. Words carry no intrinsic meaning. Insofar as they evoke something visceral—a picture in your mind’s eye, say, or what feels like “intuitive understanding”—it is because they serve as a sign pointing to something you’ve experienced. More, our memories are notoriously unfaithful. Even when we think we remember, we are so often wrong.
This is why, reader, you and I can never know whether we experience the same color when we both point to a leaf and say “green.” It is also, I think, why the unthinkable urgency of intense suffering is so difficult to grasp, and so often eludes us entirely. No permutation of language can transmit the meaning of “suffering” itself; it is not a matter of finding the right words or the right author or poet. Without a landmark in our minds composed of first-person experience, even the most elegant linguistic sign is left pointing to a void.
While memory can assist us, it cannot complete the task. Think back to the last time you were consumed in pain. Can you summon the very essence of this experience, a visceral understanding of the sheer sensation? I suspect not. There is a crevasse standing between the experience itself and the mark it leaves in our minds.
An exception and a tragedy
An understanding of intense suffering eludes us, albeit with one exception. During a time of suffering, this crevasse dissolves and our mental representation of the experience converges with the experience itself. It is then alone we might catch a glimpse of suffering’s otherwise-unthinkable urgency.
And yet the unthinkable urgency of intense suffering prevents us from recognizing it as such. When we ourselves undergo the worst, our minds and bodies scream in a deafening tone. We do not regard the urgency, the suffering itself, in abstract or conceptual terms. They are not things to be pondered; they are within us, experienced directly without the mediating influence of words and symbols. During these times, empathy is not merely impossible but unthinkable. This is not a character flaw; the most altruistic among us does not think of others when she is drowning.
Nonetheless, it is tragic.
During the rare occasion during which we viscerally understand the unthinkable urgency of intense suffering, we are unable to generalize the sensation to others. And when, thank God, the agony subsides and our minds return from its all-consuming hell, again capable of empathy, the visceral sense of urgency has taken flight.
Looking back, it is difficult to summon conceptually what we went through but impossible to summon it emotionally. We rewrite our own history, recasting sheer suffering as “type 2 fun,” or “a learning experience,” or simply failing to remember it at all. Even if we manage to avoid these cognitive traps, the crevasse remains—an impassable gulf standing between us and a full appreciation of pain.
Nonetheless, I think there is a window through which we can steal a glimpse. There are times of great pain that fall below the world-dissolving threshold I have described. Our minds remain, however burdened.
Five years ago, my Boy Scout troop went backpacking in Denali State Park (next to the national park). It is probably the most “rugged” thing I’ve ever done, and it would have been a good experience if we had brought enough food.
Long story short, the Scouting group that organized the trip for us decided that “one serving” of a freeze-dried meal really meant one full meal. I don’t really know how this happened, since they were gracious and conscientious enough to procure me freeze-dried vegan backpacking food. Anyway, as you can see in the picture, 380 calories isn’t exactly a hearty dinner for a 16 year olds hauling his 30 pound backpack for miles on end.
Multiply that by ~3 and maybe throw in a Clif bar, and you’ve got something like 1300 calories a day, probably less than half of what we were burning. Oh yeah, and inhaling some scrumptious carbs every few hours prevented us from reaching the energizing, hunger-neutralizing effects of uninterrupted ketosis.
An important aside
Five short paragraphs above, I wrote the following:
Looking back, it is difficult to summon conceptually what we went through but impossible to summon it viscerally. We rewrite our own history, recasting sheer suffering as “type 2 fun,” or “a learning experience,” or simply do not remember it at all.
Despite my very own words, I utterly failed to do my memory justice. Instead, I slipped from a solemn and earnest meditation on suffering into the tone of a sardonic yet playful memoir. My words drip with contemptuous disregard for the memory they are supposed to represent, serving instead to entertain and cast myself as the type of person who can make jest of his own misfortune.
I could rewrite those four brief paragraphs under “In Alaska,” but I will instead preserve them as a testament to the ease with which we rewrite history, if merely through a disingenuous tone.
For much of human history, periods of famine were a regular occurrence. Even today, far too many people go hungry on a daily basis. I make no claim to have been placed in a uniquely burdensome situation. None of this, however, negates how utterly terrible the hunger was. In hedonic terms, it was likely the worst week of my life.
VI The Window
My week in Alaska was the closest I have ever come to grasping the unthinkable urgency of hunger—not only for myself, but for the 690 million humans with access to fewer than 1800 calories per day and untold billions (trillions?) of wild animals withering away under the silent brutality of nature. Comforted by my knowledge that the nutritional abundance of modernity lay just a few days in my future, this week was a mere shadow of the suffering that hunger can bring.
Sitting here, on a park bench in suburban Maryland, I cannot summon this sense of urgency that was directly manifest to me in the Alaskan backcountry. But for language’s fundamental inadequacies, it indeed serves a profoundly important role; by encoding the raw suffering into words and concepts—signposts and monuments to the memory they embody—I can retain a conceptual, abstract understanding of the unthinkable urgency of suffering in spite of that impassable emotional crevasse.
This is why I can, and am, writing these words, and it is why I am confident that they are true. While still in Alaska, I turned my raw, non-symbolic conscious experience of hunger into words, and have preserved these like a souvenir ever since.
I’m not sure what I should do with this information. There is no cosmic justice in suffering on behalf of others, in living burdened by its unthinkable urgency. Yet there is something like cosmic justice in acting to reduce the worst suffering in our world. I do not even know where to start.
Factory farming seems a reasonable place, but wild animals plausibly suffer far more. The moral purity of veganism, though commendable, may not be the most tractable or urgent; few among us want animals to suffer. Might we reduce suffering the most by replacing the identitarian issue of personal dietary consumption with that of the maiming and castration of farm animals without anesthesia? How hard would it be, how much would it increase the price of a chicken breast or package of bacon, to give these animals a bit of pain relief first? A penny? A dime? How unthinkably cruel are we to not merely permit but inflict this torture upon them at so low a price?
Among our own species, let us rectify the tragic shortage of pain relief in low-income countries. And let us stare the very worst conditions right in their face, though merely as a first step to their mitigation. Cluster headaches, akathisia, and locked-in syndrome come to mind. I will not provide links; you may search for them if you wish. Elimination of these things and others like them may be the most morally pressing issue facing humanity.
There is nothing beautiful about pain or poetic about agony. The world is not just. There is no virtue, no hidden meaning to be found.
And I hope that my words, enjoyable neither to read nor to write, might help to reduce the worst among it. Thank you for reading.