Most Marginal Funding Week posts understandably focus on an organization’s own funding gap and what it could accomplish with additional money.
FarmKind is taking a different approach. We’re deliberately not making an ask for FarmKind’s own operating costs in this post.
Our mission is to support the animal movement by raising funds from the general public for some of the most effective charities tackling factory farming. We work with experts including Animal Charity Evaluators and grant-makers at major foundations focused on effective charity to identify promising charities, then build tools and campaigns designed to get new donors supporting them.
So rather than asking people who already think carefully about effective giving to move more of their donations toward us, we’re particularly interested in whether EA Forum readers can help us bring additional money into effective animal advocacy from people who don’t donate to effective charities.
Friend Match is running in several places; this post is how we’re inviting Forum readers to take part.
From November 16–30, anyone can create a personal Friend Match link and share it with people they know.
If someone donates through that link:
We don’t take a cut: all matched money goes to the charities, minus any transaction fees from your bank or card.
If the full $100,000 is unlocked through Friend Match, those matching funds would support work we estimate could help roughly 194,300 chickens, pigs, cows, sheep, goats, and fish, plus around 21 million shrimp.
The money would be distributed across FarmKind’s six recommended charities:
If someone was already going to give $100 to an effective charity and simply routes that same $100 through a matching campaign, the apparent fundraising total goes up without necessarily creating $100 of genuinely new funding.
That’s not what we’re trying to optimize for.
We’d especially like Forum readers to share Friend Match with people who would not otherwise donate to effective charities. The counterfactual value we’re hoping to create comes from those new donations, not the matching funds themselves.
That could be a friend who loves animals but mostly gives to companion-animal charities, or a family member who cares about factory farming but hasn’t found a good way to act on that concern.
But it could also be someone who isn’t especially focused on animals: perhaps they’re interested in science and technology, AI, philosophy, psychology, self-improvement, or big-picture questions about how the world works. In past testing, we’ve found that people with interests like these tend to be more receptive to FarmKind’s message, even if animal welfare isn’t already one of their concerns.
It might be a coworker, friend, family member, or someone else in your broader social circle who you think would find the case compelling.
If you inspire one of those people to give, we’ve potentially accomplished two things:
That second part may matter beyond this two-week campaign if some of those people become monthly or repeat donors.
We don’t know in advance how well this will work.
One uncertainty is simply how willing people are to ask people they know to donate. Generating a link is easy; actually messaging someone is a bigger social ask.
We’re also curious about what actually motivates someone to give when a friend or family member reaches out. Is it the matching offer, concern for animals, trust in the person sharing, or something else? That’s harder to capture in our quantitative data, so firsthand feedback could be especially useful.
Another is whether results will be broad or highly concentrated. It’s possible that hundreds of people each inspire someone to donate. It’s also possible that most sharing produces nothing and a small number of unusually effective advocates generate a large fraction of the donations.
We’re planning to track things including:
We’ll report these across the whole campaign, not just referrals from this post, so we won’t be able to say how much came from the Forum.
That should help us decide whether Friend Match is worth repeating and, if so, whether future versions should focus on broad participation or more heavily support the people who are unusually good at bringing others in.
There are also limits to what we’ll learn. In particular, seeing that a donation came through someone’s Friend Match link doesn’t by itself prove that the donation was counterfactual. We do have a post-donation survey that asks donors questions that help us assess this, but not everyone completes it. Our hope is that explicitly encouraging people to reach outside the existing effective-giving community makes counterfactual donations substantially more likely.
There’s also some uncertainty around the long-term value of recurring donations generated by the campaign, since some monthly donors may cancel after the matched first month.
Our main ask is simple:
Think of people you know who probably wouldn’t otherwise donate to an effective charity, but who you think could be receptive to FarmKind’s message. Generate your Friend Match link, and send it to them.
Generate your Friend Match link →
We’ll have ready-made messages on the Friend Match page, so you don’t have to figure out what to say from scratch.
And if you participate, we’d love to hear what you learn. If someone tells you what convinced them to donate, what stopped them, or what part of your message resonated, we’d be grateful if you shared that with us. We’d also welcome feedback on the experiment itself, including weaknesses in our approach to counterfactuality or things we should make sure to measure.
Thanks for helping us try something a little different this Marginal Funding Week!