Perhaps because I like saying overrated/underrated.
But also because overrated/underrated is a quick way to provide information. "Forecasting is underrated by the population at large" is much easier to think of than "forecasting is probably rated 4/10 by the population at large and should be rated 6/10"
Over/underrated requires about 3 mental queries, "Is it better or worse than my ingroup thinks" "Is it better or worse than my ingroup thinks?" "Am I gonna have to be clear about what I mean?"
Scoring the current and desired status of something requires about 20 queries "Is 4 fair?" "Is 5 fair" "What axis am I rating on?" "Popularity?" "If I score it a 4 will people think I'm crazy?"...
Like in some sense your right that % forecasts are more useful than "More likely/less likely" and sizes are better than "bigger smaller" but when dealing with intangibles like status I think it's pretty costly to calculate some status number, so I do the cheaper thing.
Also would you prefer people used over/underrated less or would you prefer the people who use over/underrated spoke less? Because I would guess that some chunk of those 50ish karma are from people who don't like the vibe rather than some epistemic thing. And if that's the case, I think we should have a different discussion.
I guess I think that might come from a frustration around jargon or rationalists in general. And I'm pretty happy to try and broaden my answer from over/underrated - just as I would if someone asked me how big a star was and I said "bigger than an elephant". But it's worth noting it's a bandwidth thing and often used because giving exact sizes in status is hard. Perhaps we shouldn't have numbers and words for it, but we don't.
As a response to the Worst Boyfriend Ever discourse, Fran wrote:
The “Worst Boyfriend Ever” discourse has been completely detached from reality, in my opinion. I feel like I am watching young children trying and failing to learn integration. They are wrong at every step and wrong at the conclusion. They refuse to consult a textbook or a qualified tutor, and I can’t quite tell what prompted them to try in the first place. It is discussed like a game. Imagine we spoke of murder this way.
“I’m pretty sure there’s a murderer running around, should I dox him?” “I find this writing on murdering beautiful, though there may be actual murder victims,” “If you know someone who has been murdered, please contact a journalist! Or dm, I don’t know, me? Or you could always dm @lemon_lover_always_yummy, they have karma on LessWrong.”
They do not know how reporting to the police works, they do not know what resources are available, they do not have a deep model of mental health, of PTSD following rape, of rape culture.
While I do have some model of these things, I probably don't have the model that Fran does. She would probably have had useful suggestions on the tweets I wrote. But I got sick of reading about Worst Boyfriend Ever's activities as if they were just jokey jokes, when it seemed that alongside writing about rape, he was likely also doing it. And that women might be scared to come out and say so.
I know Fran cares about this and will work hard on it, but if she is to run a project doing this work, I would ask she talk accurately about others working towards similar goals.
TraceWoodgrains claims one person told him that WBE had sexually assaulted a friend. One of WBE's stories matches a womans account in which he assualts her. He has many other stories where he describes rape. Why is only one of them true? Some private information.
I am no paragon here, and would prefer someone else was handling this.
A blogger (Worst Boyfriend Ever) who writes accounts of rapes went to Manifest Summer Camp. He was kicked out
Austin Chen offered him a ticket to manifest, then rescinded it
I looked into Worst Boyfriend Ever. There are some 3rd hand accounts of sexual assualt. He claims his stories are true except for the illegal bits
I said he was probably a rapist. I stand by it.
People from near me on twitter argued that actually he wasn't, or that it was just a kink, or whatever, whatever, whatever
Ugh. Horrible.
I like to call hits and misses. And so, while I have argued this forum is sometimes too sensitive about gender issues or too guilt prone, I would like to give credit that I am glad it seems very unlikely to me that that behaviour would be acceptable here and that it greives me for women to have to read that a guy who writes lurid descriptions of rape would be reflexively welcomed/defended.
My model of poeple who disagree with me is that they would roll their eyes and say 'obviously' and 'we've been saying this for years' and frankly, we still disagree on many things, but it feels right to say "yeah I agree on this point". I don't know what norms should be, but I completely understand why women wouldn't want to be in spaces where they are likely to come into contact with these people.
A single article discussing ~6 cases, written 3 years ago, several of which have been disputed as being EA/rationalist group houses, one of which was someone who has been banned for years (I think) and the other taking place in the UK, does not seem a lot of evidence about current norms in Berkeley.
I have been excluded from events and not told why. It sucks. But I feel like explaining to everyone is a big cost. And only explaining to the easy cases makes the hard cases more obvious. In a world where there are too few events (in my view) I would like event organisers to do as they want without me claiming they have broken some big norm.
But I'm sad exclusions happen, then generally suck, especially for those excluded, but sometimes for the organisers too.
I would like to have some clarity on Community Health's processes:
How many things are reported of what level of concern?
Can they give an example case and how it might be handled?
What are behaviours that might be responded to in different ways.
I think it's reasonable that even if a community doesn't know specific cases, we could know some numbers and a general sense of how things work and what is and isn't acceptable. The fear/inability to have these discussions as a community has, in my view, been a key fracture down the middle of EA for about 5 years.
Interesting take. I don't like it.
Perhaps because I like saying overrated/underrated.
But also because overrated/underrated is a quick way to provide information. "Forecasting is underrated by the population at large" is much easier to think of than "forecasting is probably rated 4/10 by the population at large and should be rated 6/10"
Over/underrated requires about 3 mental queries, "Is it better or worse than my ingroup thinks" "Is it better or worse than my ingroup thinks?" "Am I gonna have to be clear about what I mean?"
Scoring the current and desired status of something requires about 20 queries "Is 4 fair?" "Is 5 fair" "What axis am I rating on?" "Popularity?" "If I score it a 4 will people think I'm crazy?"...
Like in some sense your right that % forecasts are more useful than "More likely/less likely" and sizes are better than "bigger smaller" but when dealing with intangibles like status I think it's pretty costly to calculate some status number, so I do the cheaper thing.
Also would you prefer people used over/underrated less or would you prefer the people who use over/underrated spoke less? Because I would guess that some chunk of those 50ish karma are from people who don't like the vibe rather than some epistemic thing. And if that's the case, I think we should have a different discussion.
I guess I think that might come from a frustration around jargon or rationalists in general. And I'm pretty happy to try and broaden my answer from over/underrated - just as I would if someone asked me how big a star was and I said "bigger than an elephant". But it's worth noting it's a bandwidth thing and often used because giving exact sizes in status is hard. Perhaps we shouldn't have numbers and words for it, but we don't.
As a response to the Worst Boyfriend Ever discourse, Fran wrote:
In two of those cases, I am almost certain she is talking about me. I wrote about being unsure whether to dox WBE and to contact journalists, including tagging people who are popular on LessWrong.
But Fran elides that I was the one who said he was probably a rapist in the first place, starting much of this discourse and that earlier I expressed my discomfort at Austin inviting him to Manifest.
Later she says:
While I do have some model of these things, I probably don't have the model that Fran does. She would probably have had useful suggestions on the tweets I wrote. But I got sick of reading about Worst Boyfriend Ever's activities as if they were just jokey jokes, when it seemed that alongside writing about rape, he was likely also doing it. And that women might be scared to come out and say so.
I know Fran cares about this and will work hard on it, but if she is to run a project doing this work, I would ask she talk accurately about others working towards similar goals.
TraceWoodgrains claims one person told him that WBE had sexually assaulted a friend. One of WBE's stories matches a womans account in which he assualts her. He has many other stories where he describes rape. Why is only one of them true? Some private information.
I am no paragon here, and would prefer someone else was handling this.
cw rape
Context:
I like to call hits and misses. And so, while I have argued this forum is sometimes too sensitive about gender issues or too guilt prone, I would like to give credit that I am glad it seems very unlikely to me that that behaviour would be acceptable here and that it greives me for women to have to read that a guy who writes lurid descriptions of rape would be reflexively welcomed/defended.
My model of poeple who disagree with me is that they would roll their eyes and say 'obviously' and 'we've been saying this for years' and frankly, we still disagree on many things, but it feels right to say "yeah I agree on this point". I don't know what norms should be, but I completely understand why women wouldn't want to be in spaces where they are likely to come into contact with these people.
Discussing EA drama on the forum might be bad, but discussing it on twitter is, in my view, worse.
A single article discussing ~6 cases, written 3 years ago, several of which have been disputed as being EA/rationalist group houses, one of which was someone who has been banned for years (I think) and the other taking place in the UK, does not seem a lot of evidence about current norms in Berkeley.
If that wasn't your intention, fair enough. Let's try to discuss substance.
What do you think has been reported?
I have been excluded from events and not told why. It sucks. But I feel like explaining to everyone is a big cost. And only explaining to the easy cases makes the hard cases more obvious. In a world where there are too few events (in my view) I would like event organisers to do as they want without me claiming they have broken some big norm.
But I'm sad exclusions happen, then generally suck, especially for those excluded, but sometimes for the organisers too.
I would like to have some clarity on Community Health's processes:
I think it's reasonable that even if a community doesn't know specific cases, we could know some numbers and a general sense of how things work and what is and isn't acceptable. The fear/inability to have these discussions as a community has, in my view, been a key fracture down the middle of EA for about 5 years.