I recently rebooted my interview podcast, The Most Interesting People I Know (found wherever you find podcasts). I focus on EA and left-wing guests, and have been pretty involved in both communities for the last 5 years. Some example guests: Rutger Bregman, Leah Garcés, Lewis Bollard, Spencer Greenberg, Nathan Robinson, Malaika Jabali, Emily Bazelon, David Shor, and Eric Levitz. 

I just released a long conversation with Habiba Islam, an 80K career advisor and lefty, about the relationship between EA and the left. 

This is not an attempt to paper over differences between the two communities, or pretend that EA is more left-wing than it is. Instead, I tried to give an accurate description of both communities, where they are in hidden agreement, where they actually disagree, and what each can learn from the other. 

Habiba is so sharp and thoughtful throughout the conversation. We're very lucky to have her!

I hope this could be a good reference text as well as an onboarding ramp for leftists who might be open to EA. 

I think there's a real gap in the EA media-verse on the intersection of left-wing politics and EA, and we're almost certainly missing out on some great people and perspectives who would be into EA if they were presented with the right arguments and framing. 

I have no delusions that all leftists would be into EA if they only understood it better, but I think there are tons of bad-faith criticisms and genuine misunderstandings that we could better address. I think we can have a healthier and more productive relationship with the left. 

If you'd like to support the show, here are some things you can do:

  1. Personally recommend the show/particular episodes to friends. Apparently, this is how podcasts best grow their audiences.
  2. Share the podcast/episode on social media (I'm on Twitter @garrisonlovely)
  3. Rate and review the show on Apple Podcasts. 
  4. Give me feedback (anonymous form here). You can also email me at tgarrisonlovely@gmail.com

79

New Comment
4 comments, sorted by Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 3:32 AM

Another podcast episode on a similar topic came out yesterday, from Rabbithole Investigations (hosted by former Current Affairs podcasts hosts Pete Davis, Sparky Abraham, and Dan Thorn). They had Joshua Kissel on to talk about the premises of EA and his paper "Effective Altruism and Anti-Capitalism: An Attempt at Reconciliation."

This is the first interview (and second episode) in a new series dedicated to the question "Is EA Right?". The premise of the show is that the hosts are interested laypeople who interview many guests with different perspectives, in the hopes of answering their question by the end of the series. 

I'm optimistic about this podcast as another productive bridge between the EA and lefty worlds; their intro episode gave me a lot of hope that they're approaching this with real curiosity.

(I'm posting this more to recommend / mention the series rather than the particular episode though; the episode itself spent most of its runtime covering intro-EA topics in what I felt was a pretty standard way, which most people here probably don't need. That said, it did a good job of what it was aiming for, and I'm looking forward to the real heavy-hitting critiques and responses as the series continues.)

Thank you for sharing such an honest, balanced and constructive discussion of these communities by people familiar with both :-) It can be very tempting to do the opposite and I'd love to see more of this kind of thing regarding adjacent communities!

Interesting guests! I look forward to listening to some of these interviews!


However, "I think there's a real gap in the EA media-verse on the intersection of left-wing politics and EA." is somewhat untrue. After all, EA has made headlines in many left-wing media such as Vox, the New York Times, The Washington Post, the New Yorker, etc. The vast majority of EAs I've met are politically on the left. But I do hope this podcast could help get more people, who happen to be leftists, into EA.

Although I hate labels, I consider myself left of center on the political spectrum but would be very interested if someone had a similar podcast platform but for conservatives and libertarian EAs. Some of the most interesting EAs I've met happen to be libertarians. I'm all for diversity of thought in good faith.
 

excited to give this a listen. 

Anyone else listen to this podcast? I love this podcast but this episode was a though listen. Really made me think. 

https://www.iheart.com/podcast/1119-it-could-happen-here-30717896/episode/the-effective-altruism-scam-104557455/?cmp=web_share&embed=true