Thanks for making this question, and last year's version! I think this is a great idea.
In last year's one, you wrote:
We think this will accomplish a few things:
1. Encourage people to publish the posts
2. Help them prioritize between post ideas based on community feedback
3. Get directed to useful readings/resources
4. (For everyone) Get a sense of what the community is working on
I think there's another benefit, related to (or perhaps meant as implicit) in the 4th item you list: Having this public record of what people are planning on writing can help people discover whether other people are planning on writing similar things to them. This could lead to:
- them collaborating
- one person just passing their notes/drafts/thoughts to the other and then moving on to other things
- one person just dropping that plan and move onto other things (this seems less good, but still maybe better than doubled-up-effort)
It seems like it's relatively rare for two people to have very similar planned posts, but I've seen it happen at least occasionally. And there's of course no harm in two posts on a similar idea, and each person probably has a somewhat different angle. But it still seems better for the people to be made aware of each other, so they can collaborate and/or make informed decisions about whether pursuing their plan should still be their top priority.
Which suggests also a sixth, somewhat more speculative benefit: It seems possible that some people have good ideas worth writing up, but they're worried that maybe someone else has written them already or will do so soon. So they don't want to waste their effort. But if publicising one's planned posts here (or somewhere like it) becomes common practice, then these people could check here, see that no one's mentioned a similar idea, and feel more confident to invest time into the post. And if they post here, others could let them know if similar things have already been written about in the past (related to your 3rd item).
I'm planning to probably post about a lot of my planned posts here, primarily for those two extra benefits, as well as the 3rd item you mention.
I have about 60 EA-related ideas right now. This list includes some of the most promising ones, broken down by category. I am interested in feedback on which ideas people like the best.
Plus signs indicate how well thought-out an idea is:
+= idea seems interesting, but I have no idea what to say about itFundamental problems
Investing for altruists
Giving now vs. later
Long-term future
Other
I like that these generally seem quite clear and focused.
In terms of decision relevance and benefit, I get the impression that several funders and meta EA orgs feel a crunch in not having great prioritization, and if better work emerges, they may change funding fairly quickly. I'm less optimistic about career change type work, mainly because it seems like it would take several more years to apply (it would take some time from convincing someone to having them start producing research).
I'm skeptical of how much research into investments will change investments in the next 2-10 years. I don't get the impression OpenPhil or other big donors are closely listening to these topics here.
Therefore I'm more excited about the Giving Now/Later and Long-Term Future work.
Another way of phrasing this is that I think we have a decent discount rate (maybe 10% a year), plus I think that high-level research prioritization is a particularly useful field if done well.
A few years back a relatively small amount of investigation into AI safety (maybe 20 person years?) led to a huge change from OpenPhil and a bunch of EA talent.
I would be curious to hear directly from them. I think that work that influences the big donors is the highest leverage at this point, and I also get the impression that there is a lot of work that could change their minds. But I could be wrong.
I'd really like to see "If causes differ astronomically in EV, then personal fit in career choice is unimportant"
I'd be interested in basically all of the Giving Now vs Later but especially: