Effective Altruism Forum
EA Forum

Hide table of contents
Comment Permalink
jackchang1101
0
0

I'm sorry if I posted a dumb question here, but I don't think it is. Are there any problems with the question?

Reply
EdoArad2
0
0

Sorry, took me a while to write the above comment after downvoting. (I should change the order next time!). Let me know if you have any further questions

Reply
See in context
by jackchang110
1 min read1 answer 6

1

AI safetyForecastingAI forecasting
Frontpage

Most common people feel AGI is far from us intuitively. Some even think AGI will never be invented (Instead, we think AGI is 98% possible before 2200).

According to EA communtity's and experts' predictions, There's  50% chance that first AGI appears  before 2040-2050. I've surfed online for a long time, but I couldn't find essays in common words  to persuade computer science outsiders to believe this.  Would anyone share me about essays talking about this?

1

0
0

Reactions

0
0
New Answer
New Comment

1 Answers sorted by
Top

Joseph C

1
0
0

Show them ChatGPT. Also, current estimates have dropped on Metaculus to a median of 2032, not 2040-2050.

Comments6
Sorted by
New & upvoted
Click to highlight new comments since:
EdoArad3
0
0

I downvoted this post, even though I appreciate the effort you want to put into explaining the risks and timelines of AGI to outsiders of CS. This is for several reasons:

  1. I generally oppose "persuading person X to believe in Y", unless that person is a relevant decision-maker and the belief is something that we understand very well why it is true.
  2. The aggregated community/expert prediction shouldn't be taken as anything other than it is, and is definitely not something we should be sure about ourselves. In fact, views regarding exactly this question vary widely from person to person.
  3. Persuading people that some future event is p% likely seems weird to me, in this case. I'm not sure exactly why, maybe at least something like "without knowing the particular person's priors we can never send them information to convince them of any particular probability", but I think it's articulateable without bayespeak.
Reply
jackchang1101
0
0

Thanks for your response and patience very much.

  1. Actually, this is not just for persuading others, it's actually persuading myself. I a CS outsider, and I really don't understand why many people are confident that AGI will be created someday. 2.Of course predictions may not be accurate, and it's a personal view. But I think there must be some reasons why you predict AGI is 50% in 2040, not 10%.
Reply
EdoArad3
0
0

Those are great questions, sorry if I misinterpreted your original intent. 

This is a technically complicated question, but I think Holden Karnofsky tackles those questions rather well in his blog. Say, you could start from this post and read back to the links that interest you.

Reply
jackchang1101
0
0

Thanks. This helps really lot.

Reply
jackchang1101
0
0

I'm sorry if I posted a dumb question here, but I don't think it is. Are there any problems with the question?

Reply
EdoArad2
0
0

Sorry, took me a while to write the above comment after downvoting. (I should change the order next time!). Let me know if you have any further questions

Reply
More from jackchang110
View more
Curated and popular this week
Relevant opportunities
View more