In 2022, during the FTX scandal, I had never heard of effective altruism, and I barely remember the scandal itself.
How I wish I could be you!
In 2022, during the FTX scandal, I had never heard of effective altruism, and I barely remember the scandal itself.
How I wish I could be you!
I watched the first two episodes of The Boy Who Stole Billions, an upcoming Amazon series directed by Nanette Burstein about the convicted fraudster Sam Bankman-Fried, shown as a world premiere at DOC NYC.
In 2022, during the FTX scandal, I had never heard of effective altruism, and I barely remember the scandal itself. Today I encourage people to use EA principles for their careers and their giving, so I regularly get questions about it. The first impressions below are my own; the full summary of the two episodes was mostly written with AI. I’m writing in a personal capacity.
This post doesn’t aim to impose a reading of the series, and it isn’t a guide to answering questions on the topic. For that, the Centre for Effective Altruism’s post by @Tess Newton-Palmer on how to talk about the other FTX series, Netflix’s The Altruists (quite a month for TV shows on this topic) may be more useful for you.
TL;DR: Effective altruism is at the heart of most of the first episode. The series seems to aim at reflecting reality without painting a very negative picture of EA. It shows that earning to give is what led Sam into this sector, and also that some of the effective altruists who worked with him early on, Tara Mac Aulay in particular, pushed for more prudence and for keeping promises to investors. Over the first two episodes, Sam comes across increasingly as a gambler, more and more detached from his initial altruistic goals.
The series presents Sam as a utilitarian loner and gambler inspired by earning to give, but it also lets other voices inspired by effective altruism be heard.
My view is that the series doesn’t stray far from reality. Even though effective altruism is mostly seen through the lens of earning to give, it is directly what led Sam into this sector. The documentary leans quite heavily on EA, with several excerpts from EA conference talks, notably by Will MacAskill, whose role in Sam’s path is well documented.
There is also the testimony of Tara Mac Aulay, former CEO of the Centre for Effective Altruism and co-founder of Alameda Research. Even though she helped Sam get into crypto and co-founded the company with him, I’d say she represents effective altruism well, because she is clearly one of the sane and ethical people featured in the documentary. She explains the disagreements over risk management and business ethics, and what led her to leave.
The documentary doesn’t paint the worst possible picture of SBF (I was surprised by some of the choices, which, to me, cast a somewhat a neutral, or even somewhat positive, light on someone who committed such a massive fraud). It begins with his childhood and includes testimony from his parents. Sam also describes his anhedonia, his inability to feel pleasure or joy. It also builds a narrative of Sam as a very isolated person who makes extremely dangerous decisions.
Some members of the EA community worked for Sam in the early days. They didn’t support his decisions and tried to oppose him and slow him down: take fewer risks, test before launching, don’t break promises to investors. When decisions became far too dangerous, they judged that this was not acceptable and chose to leave. Tara and others gave Sam an ultimatum, he refused, and around half the company left. This part relies mostly on Tara’s account, and Sam gets to give his side.
So in this first episode, members of the EA community are both the people who said “making a lot of money to give it away is good” and the people who tried to bring back reason and a careful use of funds.
The series also shows that, as Sam became famous, the community put him on a pedestal, even though, according to Tara, Alameda had made no donations during her time there. She says Sam warned her that the community would believe his version over hers. She describes feeling vulnerable after leaving, with her place in the EA community and her whole social life at stake, and starting to doubt herself as the community held him up as a model.
As the series tells it, the initial motivations are clear: these are very altruistic people, Sam included. Around him are people who want to have a positive impact: Tara; Wayne Hsiung, an animal rights activist active on the EA Forum, who pushed back against earning to give; and later Nishad Singh, an early Alameda employee who went on to head engineering at FTX, who complains that they still haven’t started giving.
After the split, the company turns more and more towards people willing to take risks. Most of the new hires were not looking to have an impact; they just wanted to get rich. While the first people involved were, perhaps, altruists, FTX became a money-maximising operation.
Sam keeps reasoning in terms of expected value, for instance arguing that a 20% chance of FTX not being a flop is enough to justify it. Yet none of the people depicted as effective altruists in the series makes this kind of argument, and by then most of the early ones have left. In a way, they come across as the voice of reason. Through Tara’s voice, effective altruism is associated with prudence and with the importance of keeping promises and not deceiving people.
Over the two episodes, Sam goes further and further in pursuit of more money, more profit, without starting to give significantly, and seems more and more detached from any altruistic goal. My personal impression is of a gambler going double or nothing every three months; what the series shows is Sam’s growing delusions of grandeur. The series also points out how little was donated compared with the company’s valuation, criticises the investment in a coal-powered mine on climate grounds, and shows the money spent on advertising. In the show’s narrative, all of this seems tied to the delusions of grandeur Sam develops as the episodes go on.
His relationship with Caroline Ellison is at the heart of the second episode. The episode ends with the first signs of trouble in Alameda’s management: the firm relies mostly on its own assets, which are far too unstable.
This summary of the two episodes was mostly written with AI.
The episode opens at the FTX Crypto Bahamas conference, with celebrities and former world leaders on stage, then cuts to the collapse: Sam Bankman-Fried was found guilty of seven counts of fraud and conspiracy, about $8 billion of customer money is gone, and victims describe their losses. Sam takes part in the series through video calls from federal prison, limited to about 15 minutes a day. He says he wants “to get the truth out there”, even though the truth “has not been kind” to him.
Childhood and early ideas. Sam grows up near Stanford, where both his parents teach law. His parents describe a quiet, introverted child who didn’t fit in and responded to logic more than emotion. At a summer maths camp he meets Sam Trabucco and Gary Wang, who both play a role later. Trabucco remembers a teenager already talking about utilitarianism and expected value.
Discovering effective altruism. As a student at MIT, Sam finds the early EA community through an online forum and feels, for the first time, that he is not alone. Tara Mac Aulay explains the basic ideas: give 10% of your income and find the charities that do the most good per dollar. The series includes archive footage from EA talks, including a debate in which Will MacAskill says that, between saving a child or a Picasso from a burning building, he would save the Picasso and sell it to save many more children. Sam is drawn above all to animal welfare. Wayne Hsiung, an animal rights activist, remembers a young man who cared about neither wealth nor status. Will MacAskill suggests earning to give in finance. Hsiung thinks this would be a waste, but Sam follows MacAskill’s advice: he sees himself as bad at outreach and good at maths.
Jane Street. Sam joins Jane Street, a top trading firm where trading feels like a game. He donates six figures a year, feels no joy, and after an EA conference starts asking whether he could do more good elsewhere. With Tara, then CEO of the Centre for Effective Altruism, he maps out his options on a whiteboard. Tara shows him large price gaps for Bitcoin between exchanges. Sam, sceptical of crypto at first, realises it could be a huge trading opportunity and leaves Jane Street.
Founding Alameda Research. Sam and Tara found Alameda Research in 2017. All the equity is put in Sam’s name. Tara accepts because, as EAs, they plan to donate all profits anyway. Gary Wang builds the trading software, the team lives and works in a chaotic house in Berkeley, and investors from the EA community lend between $1 million and $100 million each, with a high level of trust because the profits are meant for charity. Nishad Singh, an EA and vegan who wanted to earn to give, joins; his wife describes his ambition and kindness. A trade between Japanese and US Bitcoin prices brings in around a million dollars a day. Tara explains that when a few thousand dollars can save a life, it becomes very hard to stop working.
Crisis and split. In early 2018 the crypto market crashes and wipes out most of the profits. Tara worked herself into the hospital. Around $15 million of crypto appears to be missing; Sam says later it was an accounting error and was recovered. The key conflict concerns a new trading bot: Tara wants it tested first, Sam agrees at a meeting with the lenders not to launch it untested, then switches it on the next day. Tara sees this as breaking a promise that put the investors’ money at risk. She also links Sam’s appetite for risk to his anhedonia, his inability to feel pleasure or joy, which he describes himself. Tara and part of the team try to buy him out and give him an ultimatum. He refuses, declares them fired, and about half the company leaves.
Sam loses most of his friends and roommates. He notes that the wider EA community took no formal position on who was right. Tara says Sam made clear that, as a rich, well-connected white man, his version would be believed over hers. She felt her place in the community, and her whole social life, were at risk. As Sam becomes a media figure, she starts to doubt herself, especially as the EA community holds him up as a model, although Alameda had made no donations while she was there. Archive footage shows MacAskill citing Sam’s success as proof that people can aim for even greater impact.
Hong Kong and new hires. Sam says he wanted to put distance between himself and the EA community to avoid a wider split, and moves Alameda to Hong Kong, then the centre of the crypto world. He recruits Sam Trabucco, who was not into effective altruism and wanted to get rich. Trabucco explains that the EAs who left were uncomfortable with almost any risk, and Sam wanted experienced traders. Caroline Ellison, a former Jane Street trader who shares Sam’s maths and EA background, also joins. Trabucco and Caroline soon run Alameda together. Sam and Caroline begin a relationship, largely through long written exchanges, which Sam insists on keeping secret.
Founding FTX. Sam decides to build a crypto exchange because exchanges earn fees on every trade. He reasons that a 20% chance of it not being a flop is enough to justify the bet. Gary Wang codes the first version. At a conference in Taiwan in 2019, Binance’s CEO, CZ, agrees to invest, which gives FTX credibility. Ryan Salame joins: he found the EA side “nuts” but opened his network to Sam. The pandemic triggers a crypto boom. FTX launches its own token, FTT, which is worth about $350 million on its first day. Sam says creating it took “a click of a button”.
Image and spending. The team builds Sam’s public persona: shorts, free T-shirts, the genius billionaire who will give everything away. Journalists, including those who put him in the Time 100, buy into it. FTX spends heavily on marketing, including deals with Tom Brady and Gisele Bündchen and $135 million for the naming rights to the Miami Heat’s arena. Nishad is increasingly uncomfortable with the spending. When CZ blocks new investors unless he is bought out, Sam buys back his stake with cash and around $600 million in FTT, a payment the series presents as decisive for what comes next.
The Bahamas. FTX moves to the Bahamas. Ryan Salame describes about half a billion dollars of real estate, charter flights for packages and a $30 million penthouse where Sam lives with about ten colleagues, including Caroline, Nishad and his wife. Sam explains that communal living helped him feel less lonely. Nishad’s wife describes a sense of mentorship from Sam. Salame describes vegan dinners where everyone flattered Sam.
Caroline. Caroline wants their relationship to be public; Sam refuses and puts the company first. The series reads out her own messages about feeling unloved and unsure of the relationship. Tension grows over Sam’s venture investments, which Caroline sees as a distraction. They break up, and working together becomes very difficult.
Giving and drift. Sam’s fortune is estimated at over $20 billion and he says he wants to give it away, but donations stay in the hundreds of millions, around $150 million against a $40 billion valuation. Nishad asks when they will really start giving. Salame and Zane Tackett visit a coal-powered crypto mining site in Kazakhstan; Sam invests anyway. Alameda makes about $5 billion of venture investments, including Anthropic, Solana and a stake in Robinhood. Nishad becomes the constant naysayer. Staff describe burnout and the open use of stimulants. Sam Trabucco quits Alameda, exhausted, leaving Caroline, Sam’s ex-partner, in charge.
Washington and the conflict of interest. To win a licence for margin trading in the US, Sam lobbies in Washington and becomes one of the biggest political donors in the midterms. He clashes with CZ, whom he reportedly described as close to the Chinese government. He says publicly that Alameda and FTX are separate, while his past relationship with Caroline, who runs Alameda, stays hidden.
The ending. A CoinDesk reporter obtains Alameda’s balance sheet: around 40% of its assets are in FTT, the token FTX created. The episode ends on the first doubts about Alameda’s financial health, and Sam says he believes Caroline leaked the document.
I hope this new spotlight on Sam Bankman-Fried and FTX won’t discourage people from using reason and evidence to do good in the world. The world faces huge problems, and we need people who take altruism seriously. The effective altruism community and the resources it has built can help them do that.
Really appreciate you writing this up and sharing it here so timely, Romain!