96

TL;DR If you are thinking about suicide, please talk to someone. It works. (call or text 988 in the USA)

I have had suicidal ideation several times in my life, and I also worked as a crisis counselor on a hotline. I have seen the results firsthand. There is enormous value in being open, honest, and vulnerable with another human being, and having them show up with acceptance, compassion, and kindness.

I’ve been meaning to write this for a year since I learned that EA Anywhere founder Marisa took her own life. I appreciate Draft Amnesty Week which allowed me to finally press Publish.

There are many reasons you might feel like your life isn’t worth living anymore. For me, I had been severely depressed for a while, and I had no hope it would get better. I didn’t want to die, per se; I just wanted the chronic pain to go away. I have a lot of empathy for people who use drugs to self-medicate, though I never did.

A common symptom is a feeling of disconnection. Feelings of worthlessness, being a burden, being embarrassed or ashamed, feeling that you cannot share your truth with others for fear of judgment, rebuke, ostracism, violence, or similar. We are social creatures. We need love and belonging. I’m deeply sorry if you feel you do not have that. But reaching out to people who are there to help is the first step.

I’ve learned there are two kinds of people in the world: those who can have a conversation involving difficult emotions in a supportive, connecting way, and those who cannot.

Younger me didn’t know such people existed. I had a very narrow worldview and grew up in a family where we didn’t manage our emotions healthily. I thought the rest of the world was either faking it like we were, or maybe there were families out there with functional relationship skills. But how would they even relate to my situation and even if they did, why would they want to help me?

Speaking as a trained crisis counselor, people on those lines absolutely want to talk to you. You are not a burden. They signed up specifically to talk to people in your situation. You are not taking resources away from others who need it more. EA believes that every human on the planet deserves health and happiness. That includes you.

Please try journaling If you’re not yet ready to open up to someone. You can type on your computer, write it out longhand, or even use a transcription app. Many people (myself included) find it very therapeutic to get thoughts out of my head and into the world. It’s also a great way to practice what you might say when you do talk to someone.

My depression was—in part—a symptom of repressing my emotions (especially anger). I worked with a therapist for years on fixing my alexithymia (inability to recognize and label emotions) and learning healthy ways to feel, regulate, and express the full rainbow of human emotions. If this is work you need to do too, please know that it is possible to do. It’s not easy, but the only way through it is to confront it head-on, in a timeline that works for you.

If you open up to someone and it doesn’t click, it’s not your fault. Please do not give up. Reach out to someone else. Hang up and try again. Try a different resource. I know that the energy required to get help can be enormous, and every setback can feel insurmountable. Just know that there is always another option. When I was at my worst, my therapist insisted I go check out a local in-person support group. He wanted me to foster a diversity of support in my life, and it worked. I still go to support group meetings to this day, at least weekly.

MentNav has a list of therapists and coaches who understand EA values if you want someone who will grok you when you talk about existential risk or scrupulosity. But don’t limit yourself. There are many more people out there than you likely realize (mentors, peers, family , friends…) who can step up and be a compassionate witness to your humanity if you are brave and feel them out with a question like “I’m struggling right now. Do you have time to talk?”

Suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary situation. In EA we take the long view. I invite you to consider what your life could be like in a week, a month, a year, a decade, or even a lifetime. How much good could you do with all that additional time after you get the help you need and deserve? Put on your oxygen mask first; Then help others.

You are not alone. You matter. There are people who want to help. Please, let them. ❤️

Wikipedia’s global list of suicide hotlines

Comments9


Sorted by Click to highlight new comments since:

Okay, real talk now, I know I have been an asshole on this forum, but now I will speak from my heart.

I wanted to kill myself as early as 10, I still do, I can't stand how miserable life is at times, and how everything I touch turns to shit. Literally, give me a grand, and bet against me on the stock market. 

No matter how much I try, how much I do, nothing turns out good, everything is shit, I have the midas-touch of shit. In the past year I can't remember a single good thing happening to me, it's all pain (some of it chronic) and misery. 

To end on a positive note, the fact why I am still here is not some greater purpose or hope for a better tomorrow. I am here because I enjoy the birds and the wilderness walks. I have owls in my local park, and I can hear them regularly, I like how crows sound, pigeons, sometimes I even see the bats dance around in the late night. 

I appreciate you being so honest here, N.I. The small beauties of nature can indeed help ground us in the world. I'm reminded of:

For many years, at great cost, I traveled through many countries, saw the high mountains, the boundless oceans. The only things I did not see were the sparkling dewdrops in the grass just outside my door.
—Rabindranath Tagore

And:

But I have forgotten one thing—the singing!
There was such a lot of singing in the villages then, 
   and this was my pleasure, too. 
Boys sang in the fields, 
   and at night we all met at the pub and sang.
The chapels were full of singing.
When the war came, 
   it was singing, singing all the time. 
So I lie; I have had pleasure. 
I have had singing.”
—Ronald Blythe in Akenfield

Noticing and savoring the small pleasures of life is a skill. I invite you to keep practicing it. ❤️

One more thing. Robin Dunbar—biological anthropologist and evolutionary psychologist —noted in his book Friends:

When our ancestors needed to increase the size of our social groups during the course of later human evolution, we had to find some way of extending our grooming circle proportionately. Increasing the time devoted to grooming was [not feasible]. The only realistic alternative was to use what time we had available more efficiently... We discovered several ways of triggering the endorphin system using behaviors that allowed us to engage in virtual grooming at a distance such that we could—in effect—groom several people simultaneously. These include laughter, singing and dancing, feasting, storytelling, and the rituals of religion, probably in that order.”

I invite you to engage in one or more of these activities with others. I personally go to stand-up comedy shows, listen to The Moth radio hour and audiobooks, and sing in a community choir. It all helps keep my demons at bay.
 

I do feel called to address the big story (that’s also usually what makes me sad and worn out), but, like you, what really brings me back is little stuff like a beautiful flower or seeing a hummingbird.

I 100% encourage you to make use of more timely resources. But you can reach out to me via the Forum messaging system or the contact info on my website, and I'll get back to you as soon as I can ❤️

This is a beautiful piece of writing, thanks for telling your story and the work you do. I'm reminded of a quote by ZeFrank:

The thoughts that I have in my head that make me feel the most lonely, because I don't think that anyone else thinks them, are also the thoughts that have the most potential to make me feel connected.

I think this line is especially important:

Speaking as a trained crisis counselor, people on those lines absolutely want to talk to you. You are not a burden.

It must be difficult given the narrow perspective you outline to realise this, but I think it's really important to understand—not all others are merely transactional, human connection has a value of its own.

Again, lovely, important piece.

Thanks for sharing this.  I assume you were struggling with suicidal ideation before becoming a counsellor?   I would hate to think that counselling was a factor, but could believe in such a pipeline.   How was the quality of your training for counselling?  Do you think it prepared you well for the worst situation you found yourself in?  I ask because my ex had a bad experience with counselling, but she would have been in the very challenging cohort.  Do you have any opinions on using LLM's for therapeutic conversations on these matters?

Yes, I went to therapy in earnest for 9 years. In my last year—once I was doing much better—I was certified as a crisis counselor (Crisis Text Line). I did that for a year before moving on to professional coaching. I still have an account on 7 Cups and sign in to have conversations from time to time.

The training was excellent. I recommend everyone take similar training: mental health first aid, compassionate listening, crisis counseling, peer support… It can help you support others, but also give you more context on the kind of support you might need and receive.

I have had bad experiences with therapists, and I've heard even worse stories. My advice: don't take it personally, don't dwell on it, and move forward to finding someone supportive.

LLMs can be helpful but they should only be used as supplemental resources. Ultimately the foundational skill I learned in therapy is how to have an honest, vulnerable, face-to-face conversation with another human being. It was relationship skills training. I don't believe LLMs are currently capable of giving that same experience.

Here's a story about a Japanese Buddhist monk who dedicated his life to suicide prevention: https://tricycle.org/magazine/ittetsu-nemoto/

Curated and popular this week
Paul Present
 ·  · 28m read
 · 
Note: I am not a malaria expert. This is my best-faith attempt at answering a question that was bothering me, but this field is a large and complex field, and I’ve almost certainly misunderstood something somewhere along the way. Summary While the world made incredible progress in reducing malaria cases from 2000 to 2015, the past 10 years have seen malaria cases stop declining and start rising. I investigated potential reasons behind this increase through reading the existing literature and looking at publicly available data, and I identified three key factors explaining the rise: 1. Population Growth: Africa's population has increased by approximately 75% since 2000. This alone explains most of the increase in absolute case numbers, while cases per capita have remained relatively flat since 2015. 2. Stagnant Funding: After rapid growth starting in 2000, funding for malaria prevention plateaued around 2010. 3. Insecticide Resistance: Mosquitoes have become increasingly resistant to the insecticides used in bednets over the past 20 years. This has made older models of bednets less effective, although they still have some effect. Newer models of bednets developed in response to insecticide resistance are more effective but still not widely deployed.  I very crudely estimate that without any of these factors, there would be 55% fewer malaria cases in the world than what we see today. I think all three of these factors are roughly equally important in explaining the difference.  Alternative explanations like removal of PFAS, climate change, or invasive mosquito species don't appear to be major contributors.  Overall this investigation made me more convinced that bednets are an effective global health intervention.  Introduction In 2015, malaria rates were down, and EAs were celebrating. Giving What We Can posted this incredible gif showing the decrease in malaria cases across Africa since 2000: Giving What We Can said that > The reduction in malaria has be
Rory Fenton
 ·  · 6m read
 · 
Cross-posted from my blog. Contrary to my carefully crafted brand as a weak nerd, I go to a local CrossFit gym a few times a week. Every year, the gym raises funds for a scholarship for teens from lower-income families to attend their summer camp program. I don’t know how many Crossfit-interested low-income teens there are in my small town, but I’ll guess there are perhaps 2 of them who would benefit from the scholarship. After all, CrossFit is pretty niche, and the town is small. Helping youngsters get swole in the Pacific Northwest is not exactly as cost-effective as preventing malaria in Malawi. But I notice I feel drawn to supporting the scholarship anyway. Every time it pops in my head I think, “My money could fully solve this problem”. The camp only costs a few hundred dollars per kid and if there are just 2 kids who need support, I could give $500 and there would no longer be teenagers in my town who want to go to a CrossFit summer camp but can’t. Thanks to me, the hero, this problem would be entirely solved. 100%. That is not how most nonprofit work feels to me. You are only ever making small dents in important problems I want to work on big problems. Global poverty. Malaria. Everyone not suddenly dying. But if I’m honest, what I really want is to solve those problems. Me, personally, solve them. This is a continued source of frustration and sadness because I absolutely cannot solve those problems. Consider what else my $500 CrossFit scholarship might do: * I want to save lives, and USAID suddenly stops giving $7 billion a year to PEPFAR. So I give $500 to the Rapid Response Fund. My donation solves 0.000001% of the problem and I feel like I have failed. * I want to solve climate change, and getting to net zero will require stopping or removing emissions of 1,500 billion tons of carbon dioxide. I give $500 to a policy nonprofit that reduces emissions, in expectation, by 50 tons. My donation solves 0.000000003% of the problem and I feel like I have f
 ·  · 8m read
 · 
In my past year as a grantmaker in the global health and wellbeing (GHW) meta space at Open Philanthropy, I've identified some exciting ideas that could fill existing gaps. While these initiatives have significant potential, they require more active development and support to move forward.  The ideas I think could have the highest impact are:  1. Government placements/secondments in key GHW areas (e.g. international development), and 2. Expanded (ultra) high-net-worth ([U]HNW) advising Each of these ideas needs a very specific type of leadership and/or structure. More accessible options I’m excited about — particularly for students or recent graduates — could involve virtual GHW courses or action-focused student groups.  I can’t commit to supporting any particular project based on these ideas ahead of time, because the likelihood of success would heavily depend on details (including the people leading the project). Still, I thought it would be helpful to articulate a few of the ideas I’ve been considering.  I’d love to hear your thoughts, both on these ideas and any other gaps you see in the space! Introduction I’m Mel, a Senior Program Associate at Open Philanthropy, where I lead grantmaking for the Effective Giving and Careers program[1] (you can read more about the program and our current strategy here). Throughout my time in this role, I’ve encountered great ideas, but have also noticed gaps in the space. This post shares a list of projects I’d like to see pursued, and would potentially want to support. These ideas are drawn from existing efforts in other areas (e.g., projects supported by our GCRCB team), suggestions from conversations and materials I’ve engaged with, and my general intuition. They aren’t meant to be a definitive roadmap, but rather a starting point for discussion. At the moment, I don’t have capacity to more actively explore these ideas and find the right founders for related projects. That may change, but for now, I’m interested in
Recent opportunities in Community
20
John Salter
· · 2m read