Longer title for this question: To what extent does misinformation/disinformation (or the rise of deepfakes) pose a problem? And to what extent is it tractable?
- Are there good analyses of the scope of this problem? If not, does anyone want to do a shallow exploration?
- Are there promising interventions (e.g.certificates of some kind) that could be effective (in the important sense)?
Context and possibly relevant links:
- Deepfakes: A Grounded Threat Assessment - Center for Security and Emerging Technology (I’ve only skimmed the beginning of this paper — would really appreciate a partial summary or an epistemic spot check of some kind)
- Misinformation (EA Forum Wiki)
- The "misinformation problem" seems like misinformation
- Deepfake video of Zelenskyy could be 'tip of the iceberg' in info war, experts warn
- Nina Schick on disinformation and the rise of synthetic media - 80,000 Hours
- Fake news in India - Wikipedia
- The spread of misinformation: A pattern we see over and over | Statistical Modeling, Causal Inference, and Social Science
I’m posting this because I’m genuinely curious, and feel like I lack a lot of context on this. I haven't done any relevant research myself.
There is a lot of thought in this post and a lot of dense context provided in the links.
Overall, "misinformation" seems like an extremely broad area. I find it difficult situating and absorbing the information presented in the links.
The OP has put a lot of content into deep fakes. This seems important, but it's unclear if this is the subject she is most interested, and it's unclear how it's related to "misinformation" overall.
I wish I had more knowledge about what misinformation is and how we should think about it, or its opposite, "Truth". For example, related to the ongoing invasion of Ukraine, Ukrainian aligned content has dominated western social media. This content isn't entirely truthful, yet it probably serves the principles of justice and freedom in a way that most people like.
Maybe a way to get more replies and engagement would be for the OP to provide a few paragraphs on what they are most interested in (maybe it is deep fakes, or maybe something else) or provide their views and concerns.