Your 2022 EA Forum Wrapped 🎁

Sharang Phadke; Sarah Cheng; Lizka; Ben_West; Jonathan Mustin

The EA Forum team is excited to share your personal ✨ 2022 EA Forum Wrapped ✨. We hope you enjoy this little summary of how you used the EA Forum as you ring in the new year with us. Thanks for being part of the Forum!

Note: If you don't have an EA Forum account, we won't be able to make a personalized "wrapped" for you. If you feel like you're missing out, today is a great day to make an account and participate more actively in the online EA community!

151 Reactions

Mentioned in

89Your EA Forum 2023 Wrapped

85Posts from 2022 you thought were valuable (or underrated)

24EA & LW Forum Summaries - Holiday Edition (19th Dec - 8th Jan)

Comments19

Sorted by

New & upvoted

Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 8:00 AM

bruce1y47

Looks fun! Thanks for this. Curious about EA forum alignment methodology!

(also happy new year to the team, thanks for all your work on the forum!)

Lorenzo Buonanno1y19

https://github.com/ForumMagnum/ForumMagnum/blob/5f08a68cfd2eb48d5a2286962cd70ddfea9a97a6/packages/lesswrong/server/resolvers/userResolvers.ts#L322-L339

I think it looks at engagement (I assume time spent on the Forum) and the comments/posts ratio.

function getAlignment(results) {
  let goodEvil = 'neutral', lawfulChaotic = 'Neutral';
  if (results.engagementPercentile < 0.33) {
    goodEvil = 'evil'
  } else if  (results.engagementPercentile > 0.66) {
    goodEvil = 'good'
  }
  const ratio = results.commentCount / results.postCount;
  if (ratio < 3) {
    lawfulChaotic = 'Chaotic'
  } else if  (ratio > 6) {
    lawfulChaotic = 'Lawful'
  }
  if (lawfulChaotic == 'Neutral' && goodEvil  == 'neutral') {
    return 'True neutral'
  }
  return lawfulChaotic + ' ' + goodEvil
}

Holly Morgan1y10

Forum Team, maybe link "alignment" at https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/wrapped to this comment rather than the Wikipedia page? (If I'd been labeled "evil" I think I'd much rather be reassured that it's for a completely irrelevant reason than linked to the D&D reference.)

Kat Woods1y3

For those who don't program, this is what ChatGPT says this code means:

"This code defines a function getAlignment that takes in an object called results and returns a string indicating a combination of good/evil and lawful/chaotic alignments.

The function first initializes two variables, goodEvil and lawfulChaotic, to the string 'neutral' and 'Neutral', respectively. It then checks the engagementPercentile property of the results object. If the engagement percentile is less than 0.33, goodEvil is set to the string 'evil'. If the engagement percentile is greater than 0.66, goodEvil is set to the string 'good'.

The function then calculates the ratio of commentCount to postCount in the results object, and uses this ratio to set the value of lawfulChaotic. If the ratio is less than 3, lawfulChaotic is set to 'Chaotic'. If the ratio is greater than 6, lawfulChaotic is set to 'Lawful'.

Finally, the function checks if both lawfulChaotic and goodEvil are equal to 'neutral'. If they are, the function returns the string 'True neutral'. Otherwise, it returns the concatenation of lawfulChaotic and goodEvil with a space in between."

I don't code, so I have no idea if this is accurate, so please let me know if it's off.

Lorenzo Buonanno1y30

I think it's accurate, but I don't know if it's clearer

Here's a shitty table that I think is clearer

Actually, ChatGPT does a decent job at that

This is arguably better than my table:

Adrià Garriga Alonso1y15

No, I think your table is substantially better than chatgpt’s because it factors out the two alignment dimensions into two spatial dimensions.

Writer1y2

I have to squint a lot to see the sense in this mapping

Lorenzo Buonanno1y10

I don't think it's meant to be taken seriously, just some whimsical easter egg

Lizka1y24

I'm really glad we made this. :)

Scanning through my strong upvotes & upvotes, here are things I think are really valuable (not an exhaustive list!^[1]), grouped in very rough categories:

Assorted posts I thought were especially underrated
Methods-ish or meta posts
Other posts I was really excited about (which don't fall neatly into other categories)
AI posts
Resources and lists
- EA Opportunities: A new and improved collection of internships, contests, events, and more.
- EA & LW Forums Weekly Summary (21 Aug - 27 Aug 22’) — the whole series
- Forecasting Newsletter: January 2022 — the whole series
- The Future Fund’s Project Ideas Competition — this is still a bank of really interesting project ideas
- See more posts like this here:
Posts I wrote or was involved with (I searched for these separately, these weren't on my "wrapped" page)
- Events, highlighting especially good content, resources
- Other posts
- Thoughts on Forum posts:
- Crossposts
  - Distillation and research debt
  - Reasoning Transparency

Offering FAANG-style mock interviews

not in the top forum posts of the year or anything, but I'd want it to get more exposure

Barry Grimes1y22

Love this! I found it really valuable to be reminded of all the posts I’ve read this year and to reflect on how they’ve shaped my thinking. Big props to everyone involved in making this.

Max Görlitz1y19

This is so awesome, much cooler than Spotify Wrapped!!

Lumpyproletariat1y12

I got LG for my forum alignment - I'm guessing that that's the most common one?

Comment if you got a different one (unless you'd rather not (I guess you could make a throwaway account so that no one judges you for being CE)).

Andrew Simpson1y8

I got neutral evil 😳

Writer1y7

I am CHAOTIC Good MUAAHAHA

Kat Woods1y4

Neutral good! Which is indeed how I identify.

I do predict that most EAs are either lawful good or neutral good.

Misha_Yagudin1y10

Looking back on my upvotes, a surprisingly few great posts this year (< 10 if not ~5). Don't have a sense of how things were last year.

Sharang Phadke1y8

If anyone has insights about what they find themselves marking as "most important" and want to share them with me, I would love to hear more about your ideas. Our goal with this is to learn how we can encourage more of the most valuable content, and your opinion is valuable!

You can message me on the Forum or schedule time to chat here.

Felix Wolf1y4

Suggestion: make the wrap up easily shareable. Download as a .jpg for example.

I had to make a screenshot on my phone which did not captured everything.

I really enjoy this feature. :)